Online Now 2517

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 1910
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 2504
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

Can Glenn Robinson Jr. really be that great?

  • rookmsu said...

    2 and 3 are both wings. Doesn't matter much. Decision for JB will be who he puts at stretch 4, or does he abandon it since McGary can't play it and go double post. JB almost always plays 1 in and 4 out.

    If hardaway plays the 2, Burke will be their only player on the floor with handles.

    Le Flama Blanca

  • Honestly though, why do we talk about Michigan basketball so much? Do UNC fans obsess over NC State? Does Syracuse obsess over Boston College? Does Kentucky obsess over Louisville? Does Duke obsess over Wake Forest?

    No, because they have bigger fish to fry than their in-state little brother programs. So, why do we obsess over Michigan, exactly?

    Repping Kennesaw, GA

    iheartvag

  • iheartvag said...

    Michigan basketball...yawn. In my entire LIFETIME, UM has made the second weekend of the tournament exactly zero times lol.

    BeeLine stopped the free fall..Just needs to build. If by some chance... a Magic/Cazzie level talent comes along, he will lead them out of the wilderness!

    Ron_in_ATL

  • Le Flama Blanca said...

    If hardaway plays the 2, Burke will be their only player on the floor with handles.

    Maybe the put that Akunne sp? fellow at 1, Burke 2, Timmy 3, GR 4, Morgan.

    They did play Novak at 4.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Btothejizer

  • Ok, Btothejizer, I would RUIN that girl on the right in your sig. So damn beautiful. Who is she?

    Repping Kennesaw, GA

    iheartvag

  • iheartvag said...

    Ok, Btothejizer, I would RUIN that girl on the right in your sig. So damn beautiful. Who is she?

    lol I forgot I had that on there, those are MD's daughters/my future wives.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Btothejizer

  • Wow, the man creates beautiful football AND beautiful women. We must save the DNA of this master specimen for future generations.

    Repping Kennesaw, GA

    iheartvag

  • Checked Rivals, 247, Scout and ESPN rankings. There seems to be quite a concensus on most of the top 100 players coming into B1G next year.

    Harris MSU 25,11, 12,11
    Robinson UM 11, 28, 29, 18
    Dekker Wisc 13, 30,30, 17
    Ferrell IU 19,34, 32, 24
    McGary UM 30,21, 21, 27
    Hollowell IU 41, 27, 40, 42
    Perea IU 43, 33, 49, 71
    Woodbury Iowa 50, 51, 45, 39
    Hammons Pur 77, 70, 73 81
    Stauskas UM 71, 84, 81, 76
    Costello MSU 83,92,94,86
    Johnson Pur 94, 80, 82, 92
    Davis Pur 96, 99,95,87
    Kaminski MSU 113, 98,88, 85
    Gesell Iowa 100, 96,87,75
    Valentine MSU 81, UR, 92, 97
    Simpson Pur 112 100, UR, UR

    Thats everyone that was rated by at least 2 of the services list. 17 total. No OSU recruits. Interesting. Listed them in order based on what would look like an overall concensus ranking of the 4 services. IU probably best class with MSU, UM and Pur all close behind. Purdue does not have a top 50 player though. Lots of new great talent coming into the league next year.

    82msuspartan

  • rookmsu said...

    No one on this board hates Michigan basketball more than me, but let's stop thinking they can't get good players. They are currently and will continue to get good players. They should. The story isn't that Michigan is good again. The story is, why the hell were they gone 15 years? And UM slaps, don't say the sanctions. They were a joke. UM's incompetence was more to blame than the joke of a sentence they received.

    I love how when you say a UM player is over rated you get responses like this. No where did I ever say Robinson wasn't good. In fact, I said he's probably top 40 which is pretty damn good. He's just not a borderline top 10 player like Rivals says he is. That's all I'm saying, his stats don't back it, his offers don't back it. So why is he ranked there?

    locd32

  • Le Flama Blanca said...

    If hardaway plays the 2, Burke will be their only player on the floor with handles.

    Like I said, could be 2010-2011 MSU all over again offensively unless THJ improves his handles or they somehow find a stretch 4. A guy like Burke can't get into the lane and control a game with 2 true bigs on the floor. They need a second threat from the perimeter or teams will pack the lane and make Burke force tough shots.

    izzoisdaman1

  • Rivals likes to do this with kids that have famous siblings. More publicity for their website because somebody from yahoo sports will write an article on it.

    Anybody remember Master P's son went from zero to four stars overnight? Yahoo picked up the story and ran it on the front page. He didn't last two seasons at USC.

    This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by Spartan8Ball on 4/14/2012 at 4:21 AM

    signature image

    Spartan8Ball

  • 82msuspartan said...

    Checked Rivals, 247, Scout and ESPN rankings. There seems to be quite a concensus on most of the top 100 players coming into B1G next year.

    Harris MSU 25,11, 12,11 Robinson UM 11, 28, 29, 18 Dekker Wisc 13, 30,30, 17 Ferrell IU 19,34, 32, 24 McGary UM 30,21, 21, 27 Hollowell IU 41, 27, 40, 42 Perea IU 43, 33, 49, 71 Woodbury Iowa 50, 51, 45, 39 Hammons Pur 77, 70, 73 81 Stauskas UM 71, 84, 81, 76 Costello MSU 83,92,94,86 Johnson Pur 94, 80, 82, 92 Davis Pur 96, 99,95,87 Kaminski MSU 113, 98,88, 85 Gesell Iowa 100, 96,87,75 Valentine MSU 81, UR, 92, 97 Simpson Pur 112 100, UR, UR

    Thats everyone that was rated by at least 2 of the services list. 17 total. No OSU recruits. Interesting. Listed them in order based on what would look like an overall concensus ranking of the 4 services. IU probably best class with MSU, UM and Pur all close behind. Purdue does not have a top 50 player though. Lots of new great talent coming into the league next year.

    That is because OSU has no commitments.

    Being called a sunshine blower is not insulting to me and I'm proud to be one.

    SpartyFever

  • iheartvag said...

    Honestly though, why do we talk about Michigan basketball so much? Do UNC fans obsess over NC State? Does Syracuse obsess over Boston College? Does Kentucky obsess over Louisville? Does Duke obsess over Wake Forest?

    Does Duke obsess over North Carolina? Does Auburn obsess over Alabama? Does Missouri obsess over Kansas?

    Yes, yes, and yes. While I don't like the UM obsession, it's just part of sports. Relax and get over it.

    RubberbandMan

  • Big M said...

    You are correct. Hiring Brian Ellerbe is the top reason. Just an absolutely horrible decision.

    The scum administration took a very hands off approach to the men's hoop program during and after their slap on the wrist from the NCAA. They put upgrades to Chrisler on hold and refused to put any money into their facilities. Beilein finally landed a basketball practice facility and major upgrades were made to the arena. Combine a litte on court success with the terribly needed facilities low and behold, they are a player again in the recruiting game. Unfortunately, they are a very recognized brand name on the national level.

    I hate them to no end, but they very much are building things in the right direction. There are a lot of parallels to our football program. They still have a long way to go and I know it will only keep Izzo's drive for his 2nd NC as strong as ever.

    BigGreenHouse

  • He's a top 5 player in the country. ~ Michigan slaps

    He sucks and Michigan will miss the tournament next year. Trey Burke is average. ~ RCMB slaps.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Harry Hood

  • According to those in the know, Little dog and McJesus are one and done, Staskos will be the best shooter in the B10 the second he arrives, Burke and Timmy will be the best backcourt in the nation, and this is a FF team next year. Not a darkhorse, not a contender. FF. They don't recruit players who might not work out. Every one of those guys is an instant contributor, and probably a star player year one. Their coach is a proven winner, the rest of the staff is outstanding.

    Meanwhile, MSU has an overrated class coming in, Izzo is "losing ground", Draymond's loss will be too much to overcome, and we will be lucky to finish in the top 5...in the B10.

    First round exit >>>>> Final 4? Because of 3 freshmen? Burke and Hardaway will be tough next year. Morgan is the definition of 7th man, but he is not horrible. Can anybody tell me who else on that current roster will be an impact player? That is a no. So, little dog comes in and plays well at the 3, McJesus is (and this is being VERY generous) a 9pt 7rbd guy. That gives you a lineup of McJesus/Morgan/Littledog/Hardaway/Burke. That is a well defined lineup. Every player can play their natural position, they have good size, good athleticism. Sounds good, on paper. Then you realize something. They have won 1 tournament game. Their coach has NEVER proven himself as a tournament ready guy. EVER! They have no bench. They have no backup PG...SG...SF...Their presumed success for 12/13 is based on littledog having a Carmelo Anthony type freshman season.

    FTR, the reason we obsess is because the media and the idiot fanbase has been slamming this scenario in our faces for months now. When you try to offer another point of view, they laugh it off like they are a dynasty. Appling/Harris(Valentine)/Dawson/Costello(Kaminski)/Paynix. With experience and depth behind them, and one of the best coaches AND staffs in the country over the last 15 years. They have a bunch of guys who shit the bed, 3 freshmen, and a coach who has NEVER had a good tournament team. Yet THEY are the ones talking about their upcoming glorious season?

    aroz13

  • aroz13 said...

    According to those in the know, Little dog and McJesus are one and done, Staskos will be the best shooter in the B10 the second he arrives, Burke and Timmy will be the best backcourt in the nation, and this is a FF team next year. Not a darkhorse, not a contender. FF. They don't recruit players who might not work out. Every one of those guys is an instant contributor, and probably a star player year one. Their coach is a proven winner, the rest of the staff is outstanding.

    Meanwhile, MSU has an overrated class coming in, Izzo is "losing ground", Draymond's loss will be too much to overcome, and we will be lucky to finish in the top 5...in the B10.

    First round exit >>>>> Final 4? Because of 3 freshmen? Burke and Hardaway will be tough next year. Morgan is the definition of 7th man, but he is not horrible. Can anybody tell me who else on that current roster will be an impact player? That is a no. So, little dog comes in and plays well at the 3, McJesus is (and this is being VERY generous) a 9pt 7rbd guy. That gives you a lineup of McJesus/Morgan/Littledog/Hardaway/Burke. That is a well defined lineup. Every player can play their natural position, they have good size, good athleticism. Sounds good, on paper. Then you realize something. They have won 1 tournament game. Their coach has NEVER proven himself as a tournament ready guy. EVER! They have no bench. They have no backup PG...SG...SF...Their presumed success for 12/13 is based on littledog having a Carmelo Anthony type freshman season.

    FTR, the reason we obsess is because the media and the idiot fanbase has been slamming this scenario in our faces for months now. When you try to offer another point of view, they laugh it off like they are a dynasty. Appling/Harris(Valentine)/Dawson/Costello(Kaminski)/Paynix. With experience and depth behind them, and one of the best coaches AND staffs in the country over the last 15 years. They have a bunch of guys who shit the bed, 3 freshmen, and a coach who has NEVER had a good tournament team. Yet THEY are the ones talking about their upcoming glorious season?

    Money post right there, it's not that Michigan will be bad next year, but they have more questions and less talent that we do and we're not getting the respect we deserve and that now includes Gary Harris getting dropped in the rankings after a phenomenal senior season where he won Mr. Basketball and emerged as the top shooting guard in the country, yet he falls from 11 to 25 for rivals???

    Michigan is losing plenty off from their team and they weren't as good as we were this year, that's a fact.

    I've been saying Robinson is a much better recruit that McGary for 4 months now, but what has he shown to garner 5 stars? Sorry, Robinson is good, but 11th is overrated for him, and 30 is still way way too high for McGary. McGary should be 60-80 and Robinson should be 25-35, no one should have Harris outside the top 15 and he's probably top 10. He was the 2nd best player in that NIKE team only to Shabazz.

    Johnny2x2x

  • Johnny2x2x said...

    Money post right there, it's not that Michigan will be bad next year, but they have more questions and less talent that we do and we're not getting the respect we deserve and that now includes Gary Harris getting dropped in the rankings after a phenomenal senior season where he won Mr. Basketball and emerged as the top shooting guard in the country, yet he falls from 11 to 25 for rivals???

    Michigan is losing plenty off from their team and they weren't as good as we were this year, that's a fact.

    I've been saying Robinson is a much better recruit that McGary for 4 months now, but what has he shown to garner 5 stars? Sorry, Robinson is good, but 11th is overrated for him, and 30 is still way way too high for McGary. McGary should be 60-80 and Robinson should be 25-35, no one should have Harris outside the top 15 and he's probably top 10. He was the 2nd best player in that NIKE team only to Shabazz.

    Gary was always 25 for rivals, he just didn't move up at all after his season as the best player in a loaded Indiana high school class. He's still 11 for scout and ESPN. Rivals is always a bit weird. for perspective the first underclassman to win Mr. Basketball in Illinois and the 4th underclassmen to ever win the Gatorade NPOY, Jabari Parker, is ranked number 2

    MooUguru

  • One and done. JB has the pipeline flowing to the NBA - look out Calipari !!!

    Signed Mitch Albom

    Mitch Knows All

  • BH Spartan said...

    He committed like 2 years ago so why would other teams offer?

    Ah, f**k that s**t. I have 9 guys who better.

    Signed,

    U. Meyer.

    Loose Stools