Online Now 1911

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 1359
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 1813
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

HS Star Ratings for Final Four Rosters

  • For all the hype Cal gets, UConn is just as loaded. As noted before, Butler isn't exactly a bunch of nobodies. VCU's best player was supposed to be a stud at Wake Forest.

    UConn
    Walker-5
    Oriakhi-5
    Lamb-4
    Napier-4
    Smith-4
    Combs-McDaniel-4
    Okwanda-4

    Kentucky
    Knight-5
    Jones-5
    Lamb-5
    Miller-4
    Liggens-4
    Harrellson-3

    Butler
    Howard-4
    Mack-3
    Smith-3
    Marshall-3
    Nored-3

    VCU
    Skeen-4
    Rodriguez-3
    Nixon-3
    Burgess-2
    Rozzell-2

    WBill19542

  • That's interesting. Surprised Mack was only a 3 and that Oriahki was a 5. This is why i want VCU.

    What is that, a Titleist? A hole in one...

    Cosmo_Kramer

  • Mack is playing like a 5. He is one of the top 10 guards in the country.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Spartyshannon

  • Spartyshannon said...

    Mack is playing like a 5. He is one of the top 10 guards in the country.

    The guy is turning it on in the tournament...every year, fans turn off the regular season and make all judgements based on what is going on in march.

    tVargMan Prime

  • WBill@ said...

    For all the hype Cal gets, UConn is just as loaded. As noted before, Butler isn't exactly a bunch of nobodies. VCU's best player was supposed to be a stud at Wake Forest.

    UConn
    Walker-5
    Oriakhi-5
    Lamb-4
    Napier-4
    Smith-4
    Combs-McDaniel-4
    Okwanda-4

    Kentucky
    Knight-5
    Jones-5
    Lamb-5
    Miller-4
    Liggens-4
    Harrellson-3

    Butler
    Howard-4
    Mack-3
    Smith-3
    Marshall-3
    Nored-3

    VCU
    Skeen-4
    Rodriguez-3
    Nixon-3
    Burgess-2
    Rozzell-2

    How does that compare to MSU's roster this year and next year?

    magicspartyman

  • magicspartyman said...

    How does that compare to MSU's roster this year and next year?

    Next season
    Roe-5
    Green-3
    Nix-4
    Sherman-4
    Payne-5
    Appling-4
    Byrd-3
    Guana-3
    Dawson-5
    Anderson-4
    Kearney-3
    Trice-3

    signature image signature image signature image

    "You make sure when you come, you got a little blood in your eye, a little blood in your eye, a little fire in your belly. We there yet?"

    PersonaNONgrata

  • VargMan said...

    The guy is turning it on in the tournament...every year, fans turn off the regular season and make all judgements based on what is going on in march.

    I watched Butler play during the regular season last year and this year. I am not making a snap judgement based on tournament play. In case you did not know, Mack was invited to an NBA camp last summer. Only the top 10 guards in the country were invited. Maybe you need to watch college basketball more instead of making snap judgements on others.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Spartyshannon

  • PersonaNONgrata said...

    Next season Roe-5 Green-3 Nix-4 Sherman-4 Payne-5 Appling-4 Byrd-3 Guana-3 Dawson-5 Anderson-4 Kearney-3 Trice-3

    Where are you getting your recruiting stars? Green was a 4 star as well as Byrd and Guana. The only 3 stars on our roster will come from this year's class in Trice and Kearney. Trice came on super late and never had his stars updated (he was Gatorade Player of the Year in Ohio) and Kearney was a 4 star turned 3 star after a sluggish senior year.

    locd32

  • locd32 said...

    Where are you getting your recruiting stars? Green was a 4 star as well as Byrd and Guana. The only 3 stars on our roster will come from this year's class in Trice and Kearney. Trice came on super late and never had his stars updated (he was Gatorade Player of the Year in Ohio) and Kearney was a 4 star turned 3 star after a sluggish senior year.

    Rivals

    signature image signature image signature image

    "You make sure when you come, you got a little blood in your eye, a little blood in your eye, a little fire in your belly. We there yet?"

    PersonaNONgrata

  • PersonaNONgrata said...

    Rivals

    eeeeewwwwwwwww

    locd32

  • Spartyshannon said...

    I watched Butler play during the regular season last year and this year. I am not making a snap judgement based on tournament play. In case you did not know, Mack was invited to an NBA camp last summer. Only the top 10 guards in the country were invited. Maybe you need to watch college basketball more instead of making snap judgements on others.

    This.

    If Mack played for a BCS team, VargMan would love him, but because Mack plays for a Mid Major he has the hate goggles on.

    Io Triumphe

  • PersonaNONgrata said...

    Rivals

    Rivals for football thumbsup Rivals for basketball nono
    Scout for football nono Scout for basketball thumbsup
    ESPN for football nono ESPN for basketball nono

    signature image

    MintBerryCrunch

  • MintBerryCrunch said...

    Rivals for football thumbsup Rivals for basketball nonoScout for football nono Scout for basketball thumbsupESPN for football nono ESPN for basketball nono

    FWIW for those that prefer "Scout" ratings. The OP contained the Rivals ratings. The Scout ratings for the Final Four team players were almost exactly the same; except for Butler whose players Scout rated lower across the board.

    Howard-3
    Mack-2
    Nored-2

    (Hayward)-2huh Same rating they gave Austin Thornton.

    I wouldn't be boasting about those differences.

    This post was edited by WBill19542 on 3/28/2011 at 4:24 AM

    WBill19542