Online Now 2903

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 2413
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 3007
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

"I seen..."

  • Clive Bixby said...

    Embrace it. It's not going anywhere. My father is in his mid 60's. He's an expert at this dialect. I always assumed it was an eastside (Detroit) thing. "I says to the guy" "so I goes to the...." "I'm with your mom and we sees this....."

    On the other hand my Mom speaks perfect english.

    To each his own. I kind of get a kick out of it. Maybe they just fit his stories well.

    The "I says" drives me nuts. My mom does it all the time. None of her kids do I think she started doing this later in life for some reason

    buckeyesparty

  • One of my kid's old Daycare teachers used to say it all the time. I cringed knowing my 2 year old was learning to talk at the time and was hearing that from this teacher 40 hours a week.

    Winston Wolf

  • Winston Wolf said...

    One of my kid's old Daycare teachers used to say it all the time. I cringed knowing my 2 year old was learning to talk at the time and was hearing that from this teacher 40 hours a week.

    I would have fired her on the spot.

    SeeGreen: "Ahhh.. whenever optimusprimal19 speaks, good things have happened."

    J T

  • jimmurphey said...

    "Me and my ________". Hear this one a lot.

    Shadow?

    Gomer

  • Nutz Interface said...

    Except as far as I know, "dove" was never a different tense of the word "dive" that was used incorrectly. "Gone" and "Went," which are also often used incorrectly—"I have went"—would be a better comparison.

    edit: actually, i'm not sure what the proper equivalent of "seen" would be for "dive"... I have dove? I have dived? I have diven?lol i guess I'd probably be most likely to say "I have dived" but I'm not sure what the correct form is.

    Actually, the fact that "seen" is the past participle makes it much more likely to replace "saw" as the past tense. The vast majority of English verbs are identical in the past tense and past participle, so children learn very early in their language development to use the same word for each. Irregular forms take longer to learn, so "I seen" would be a very common mistake with small children for a couple of years. Keeping the non-irregular form as an adult is a fairly easy change to make, linguistically speaking.

    FWIW, "dived -> dove" was an incorrect application of ablaut, making it analogous to "drive-drove." It's one of the odd (and relatively rare) changes from regular verbs to irregular.

    signature image

    ashamanAJSV

  • ashamanAJSV said...

    Actually, the fact that "seen" is the past participle makes it much more likely to replace "saw" as the past tense. The vast majority of English verbs are identical in the past tense and past participle, so children learn very early in their language development to use the same word for each. Irregular forms take longer to learn, so "I seen" would be a very common mistake with small children for a couple of years. Keeping the non-irregular form as an adult is a fairly easy change to make, linguistically speaking.

    FWIW, "dived -> dove" was an incorrect application of ablaut, making it analogous to "drive-drove." It's one of the odd (and relatively rare) changes from regular verbs to irregular.

    I agree that using "seen" instead of "saw" makes you sound like a child.

    get the new Nike MSU font: http://tinyurl.com/spartansfont

    Nutz Interface

  • Nutz Interface said...

    I agree that using "seen" instead of "saw" makes you sound like a child.

    Ebonics

    What is that, a Titleist? A hole in one...

    Cosmo_Kramer

  • How about hung and hanged? "the convict was hanged last night for the death of a rival message board poster" yet "hung" sounds correct...

    Should I be saying "I'm really hanged over from all that malt liquor last night?"

    signature image

    Dr Leo Spaceman

  • Dr Leo Spaceman said...

    How about hung and hanged? "the convict was hanged last night for the death of a rival message board poster" yet "hung" sounds correct...

    Should I be saying "I'm really hanged over from all that malt liquor last night?"

    That one always messes me up too, but it makes sense. You can consider two separate definitions of "hang:" one kills somebody, and the other refers to hanging something up. "Hanged" is the past tense for the first one, "hung" for the rest. No, I don't know where that came from.

    signature image

    ashamanAJSV

  • ashamanAJSV said...

    Actually, the fact that "seen" is the past participle makes it much more likely to replace "saw" as the past tense. The vast majority of English verbs are identical in the past tense and past participle, so children learn very early in their language development to use the same word for each. Irregular forms take longer to learn, so "I seen" would be a very common mistake with small children for a couple of years. Keeping the non-irregular form as an adult is a fairly easy change to make, linguistically speaking.

    Which begs the next question, are the people who say "I seen" using it in place of "I've seen" or "I saw?" As in, "I've seen that movie" or "I saw that movie."

    This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by J T on 5/14/2012 at 12:39 PM

    SeeGreen: "Ahhh.. whenever optimusprimal19 speaks, good things have happened."

    J T

  • My mom and her tea buddies have recently starting using "be" instead of "am". Like "I be tired" or " I be hungry". It pisses me the hell off.

    Sp4rt4ns

  • Illinoissssssssssssssssss

    Location: Mumbai, India

    sparty419

  • For those of you seriously bothered by a slight deviation from perfect English, keep in mind that in a two way communications, it is the responsibility of the sender to insure a message is clear. When the phrase in this topic is used, the meaning is perfectly clear which creates a perfect communication. What could possibly be wrong with that?

    These phrases are more dialect than un-education. I know the proper use of many terms but do not use them, by preference. I love using terms that my father or grandfather used.

    I work with many people who do not have “formal” educations who are smart and productive as hell and can run circles around our college kids.

    Finally, to the dude who claims he doesn’t like interacting with “common folk”………you are missing out. There are great people out there, all ages, all colors, all levels of education.

    Freak

  • Accrost

    Heighth

    Picture of my family and I

    Zeke4H

  • Zeke4H said...

    Accrost

    Heighth

    Picture of my family and I

    Illinoizeee

    What is that, a Titleist? A hole in one...

    Cosmo_Kramer

  • Will Brasky said...

    I think getting on someone's case for using "went" in the place of "gone" is a bit too nitpicky. Many extremely educated sophisticates use those interchangeably.

    I disagree, that one is very easy to get right... It's "have gone" and "went." Try saying things like "I have went to the store" or "I gone fishing last weekend" and I don't think you'd argue they're interchangeable anymore? I don't think it's very common that people, educated or not, mix the two up. I think it's a very good comparison to "seen/saw."

    get the new Nike MSU font: http://tinyurl.com/spartansfont

    Nutz Interface

  • Nutz Interface said...

    I disagree, that one is very easy to get right... It's "have gone" and "went." Try saying things like "I have went to the store" or "I gone fishing last weekend" and I don't think you'd argue they're interchangeable anymore? I don't think it's very common that people, educated or not, mix the two up. I think it's a very good comparison to "seen/saw."

    You gone went there now.

    Zeke4H

  • Zeke4H said...

    Picture of my family and I

    This is annoying because so many people seem to think that "me" is improper, so they think they're being correct by using "I." A similar example is "myself," as in "please contact Steve or myself."

    85Grad

  • Mid Michigan vernacular. Also "them guys".

    "I think the world is run by C students" Al Mcguire

    rob

  • 85Grad said...

    This is annoying because so many people seem to think that "me" is improper, so they think they're being correct by using "I." A similar example is "myself," as in "please contact Steve or myself."

    I blame De La Soul.

    Sp4rt4ns

  • jimmurphey said...

    "Me and my ________". Hear this one a lot.

    Uncle

    Thepostmen

  • Who else seen the leprechaun? say yaa.

    attachment

    Duke Silver

  • J T said...

    Which begs the next question, are the people who say "I seen" using it in place of "I've seen" or "I saw?" As in, "I've seen that movie" or "I saw that movie."

    It's almost certainly replacing "I saw." Certain dialects might swap a few words, but they very very rarely eliminate entire tenses.

    signature image

    ashamanAJSV

  • Jaheab said...

    "I seen" and most of the other grammatical problems highlighted in this tread bother me, not that I always speak the King's English but at least I don't live anywhere where "y'all" is common. "Y'all" really grinds my gears.

    Living in Texas I can see the use for y'all, but what is funny is when people pluralize it as all y'all.

    Inglewood Jack

  • The most endangered species in our nation isn't a big woodpecker or some freshwater fish. It's the tongue in our heads. Listen to the truncated bastard language of today. The average vocabulary is a third of what it was 100 years ago. The landscape of vocabulary is being hacked down and grubbed up by the drivel of pop culture, poisoned by lazy obscenity, infantilized by a youth-obsessed media.

    Ask people today what the definition of syntax is and they will probably tell you it's something Vegas brothels have to pay the IRS

    fallenangle