Online Now 2953

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 2140
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 2884
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

Is organically grown food worth the extra money?

  • LoneWolfSparty said...

    No.

    Organic: Grown in poo. Non-organic: Grown using chemical fertilizers.

    More people die of e. coli and other bacteria than from chemicals.

    The problem with this logic is that lots of "non-organic" food is frequently contaminated with e-coli.
    Just ask Jimmy Johns.

    Non-organic: poo and chemical fertilizers
    Organic: poo fertilizer

    Phil McCrackin

  • rob said...

    I don't understand this thinking. You and the rest of the country have been eating it for 50+years and other than the high fructose corn syrup/sugar obesity problem. people are heathier and living longer than ever before.

    didn't say it would kill you, just said that I don't want it

    and you have to admit the the level of engineering has really ramped up over the last 10 - 15 years

    the "animals" out there today barely resemble the animals that people were eating 50 years ago

    We've got depth. We've got numbers.

    ninowesco

  • ninowesco said...

    the "animals" out there today barely resemble the animals that people were eating 50 years ago

    Could that be the result in the improvement in their diets as well? After all people don't look the same as they did 40 years ago either. In the 1960's a 200lb high school football lineman was a rarity. Now 300lb linemen are common place. Is that good????? People today are huge in size compared to what they were 40 years ago. But 40 years ago we only had 1/100th of the fast food outlets available to the public as you have today. today there are 10 on almost every commercially zone block. 40 years ago People ate scheduled balanced meals and less food. They don't do that today.

    This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by rob on 4/12/2012 at 5:28 PM

    "I think the world is run by C students" Al Mcguire

    rob

  • ninowesco said...

    didn't say it would kill you, just said that I don't want it

    and you have to admit the the level of engineering has really ramped up over the last 10 - 15 years

    the "animals" out there today barely resemble the animals that people were eating 50 years ago

    you're full of it mister.

    sincerely,

    attachment

    AMwood

  • Motown Spartan said...

    But wouldn't the price come down of it were produced in mass quantities?

    I took a random class on economics at MSU, it was very interesting stuff.

    Warning, mind dump. My two cents - one cent at a time - 1) People forget that a lot of the modifications happen for a reason, and working back for the sake of working back is retarded. 2)There is no FDA regulation governing what is "organic".

    1) Pasteurization is a good idea. There are people that make up bullshit "holistic" benefits to unpasteurized, and I don't think the gov't should stop you from drinking unpasteurized, but avoiding the process is really dumb.

    2) Every now and then, something tastes better, every now and then, something is bad for you. Take virginiamycin for instance, it isn't known to be bad for you but it isn't good either. It is used for ethanol producing grain as well as feed, and can pass through more than needed. There are several lobbies trying to block the FDA from becoming more stringent. I am aware of both "organic" and regular dairy farms that use the same levels of the aforementioned. On the other hand, you have to wonder about the growth hormones being pumped into cows.I'd be cautious

    3) Salt as a preservative is effective. It's on the generally regarded as safe (GRAS) list but it can fuck up your sodium levels if you go apeshit on something. Nitrites for curing meat might be linked to stomach cancer. Adding some acids to lower the pH is practically harmless.

    4) I have no problem with genetically modified crops. Montsanto gets a lot of shit but most of it is misunderstood. Some stuff tastes better so that's a preference, not health decision. Same with irradiation, it's unfortunate that the method isn't implemented more often.

    Basically go case by case and see what food has/neglects something.

    Foxbat

  • Motown Spartan said...

    Or is it just another way for hippies and weirdos to feel like they are saving the world?

    Organic vegetables have a better nutrient profile than inorganic fertilized vegetables. The increase in non-essential nutrients (you can grow plants with very few nutrients present) also keeps the soil at a higher quality for a longer period of time.

    However, inorganic fertilizers allow for extremely well controlled releases of nutrients to help maximize yield (organic fertilizers have a variance and a lower yield can result from not having enough of a nutrient at an exact time.

    Organic fertilizers are renewable. Cows are pretty much always going to poop, so there's that. Most inorganic fertilizer ingredients are non-renewable and will, at some point in the future, run out.

    Beardy

  • Foxbat said...

    4) I have no problem with genetically modified crops. Montsanto gets a lot of shit but most of it is misunderstood. Some stuff tastes better so that's a preference, not health decision. Same with irradiation, it's unfortunate that the method isn't implemented more often.

    Basically go case by case and see what food has/neglects something.

    GMO's are totally fine and we have all been eating them for some time. It gets murky with cross breeding and trade bans with places like europe and stuff, though. Irradiation has a hill to climb to the mainstream because food treated by it required to include that on the label. The general population is absolutely food retarded and will see that and think their food is radioactive so manufacturers are currently hesitant about using irradiation despite its effectiveness.(And safety)

    Anyways, there was a good article recently in the IFT(Institute of Food Technology) magazine about separating fact from bullshit in organic food. I was gonna link it here but it looks like you need to be an IFT member to read it. But it shed light on quite a bit of bullshit, including the belief that organic food is more nutritious and that regular food is poisoning you with pesticide.

    This post was edited by All Ages Shows on 4/12/2012 at 5:17 PM

    All Ages Shows

  • Also, OP, the answer is no.

    All Ages Shows

  • Notice how many snack products use cottonseed oil?
    Its cheap and because cotton isn't classified as a food product growers can use many more agrichemicals than are used for corn.

    GRR Spartan

  • There has never been a society free of famine that hasn't had to do some sick shit to its food supply. Factory farming methods and GMO are ascendant because they are efficient. And if you want to return to a hazy past where everything is grown in the earth with manure and livestock is allowed free range, that's fine. Just tell me which 3 billion of the world's 7 billion people you want to die horribly, simply so we can get back to an organic carrying capacity.

    This post was edited by numberonealcove on 4/12/2012 at 5:35 PM

    numberonealcove

  • A.M. wood said...

    you're full of it mister.

    sincerely,

    what the eff (to the pic)?

    DavidsonNCCock

  • numberonealcove said...

    And if you want to return to a hazy past where everything is grown in the earth with manure and livestock is allowed free range, that's fine. Just tell me which 3 billion of the world's 7 billion people you want to die horribly, simply so we can get back to an organic carrying capacity.

    No thank you, I'd prefer not to eat cow shit.

    "I think the world is run by C students" Al Mcguire

    rob

  • Motown Spartan said...

    Or is it just another way for hippies and weirdos to feel like they are saving the world?

    No, almost as big a hoax as homeopathy.

    "No one cares what you know, until they know how much you care." Mark Dantonio

    GTASpartan87

  • ninowesco said...

    don't care if the poors can't get it

    I'm not subjecting me and mine to genetically engineered, chemically injected "food"

    Oh really.....ever had corn on the cob? Guess what, you ate genetically modified food! Ha ha.....

    "No one cares what you know, until they know how much you care." Mark Dantonio

    GTASpartan87

  • A.M. wood said...

    this. i believe so everyone can afford them, organic foods should be grown on bigger farms and maybe not use poop (which is expensive) but maybe something synthetic that does the same thing as poop.

    Uh, if you use something "synthetic" then we are no longer talking about an allegedly "organic" food item.......

    "No one cares what you know, until they know how much you care." Mark Dantonio

    GTASpartan87

  • GTASpartan87 said...

    Uh, if you use something "synthetic" then we are no longer talking about an allegedly "organic" food item.......

    You fail at sarcasm.

    Motown Spartan

  • GTASpartan87 said...

    Oh really.....ever had corn on the cob? Guess what, you ate genetically modified food! Ha ha.....

    No shit Sherlock.

    The point is that it should be avoided, if possible

    We've got depth. We've got numbers.

    ninowesco

  • LoneWolfSparty said...

    No.

    Organic: Grown in poo.
    Non-organic: Grown using chemical fertilizers.

    More people die of e. coli and other bacteria than from chemicals.

    I hate when I agree with you.

    Sparty is our mascot, we are Spartans.

    ConQueso

  • ninowesco said...

    No shit Sherlock.

    The point is that it should be avoided, if possible

    Love all your name calling in this thread....as per usual....

    Point is, you are, and have been, eating many genetically modified food. And guess what, if not for those genetic modifications there is no way we could feed the billions of people that we do.....

    This thread is pretty ironic considering we, well, most of us, went to MSU, the home of W.J. Beal.

    William James Beal - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_James_Beal

    en.wikipedia.org

    "No one cares what you know, until they know how much you care." Mark Dantonio

    GTASpartan87

  • Motown Spartan said...

    You fail at sarcasm.

    Yeah, I got it too late......this topic always gets me riled up and I end up posting before thinking....

    "No one cares what you know, until they know how much you care." Mark Dantonio

    GTASpartan87

  • The question was is it worth it. I'd say it depends on what you mean by organic. Organic food from meijer; you might as well just buy the non-organic stuff. But, what are you buying this food for? Let me answer, you're buying it for THE TASTE. MSU is a school with a lot of farmers. Buddy up to one of them, and have them serve you a steak from one of their cows, with some of the tomatos that they grew. Now that stuff is worth it. Or even the MSU food Co-op, go buy something from their stand and tell me it doesn't taste better than what you would get at meijer. So I say, if you want to serve up a really delicous meal every once in a while, going the extra mile to get the real stuff is worth it.

    This post was edited by Thepostmen on 4/12/2012 at 6:10 PM

    Thepostmen

  • La Paz Spartan said...

    The only thing that matters is whether it's local.

    I tend to agree.

    I believe in organic food, in theory but as others have said, there's really no reputable way to prove something is organic.

    1. I have a friend who works for a company that certifies food as organic. She works for the food corporations that hire her to certify them as organic. Who does she answer to? Herself and the food companies that hire her. What incentive does she have to be extra strict with these corporations on giving them the "organic" label? She has to compete with other organic certification companies in order to retain her clients. If she is too strict, the food companies can drop her and go for someone else.

    2. Local is the way to go imo. A local farmer is someone you can ask questions directly relating to their practices. Heck, you can go check out the operation yourself if you want. That's more helpful than buying an apple that was mass produced at a giant farm on the west coast, then shipped 3,000 miles and just trusting that it's organic. Their farm is likely an operation they can oversee themselves and not a mega factory.

    3. I still buy organic a lot for differnet reasons. I like black beans and the Meijer brand organic black beans have about 80% less sodium than the standard brand. But in the produce section, I'll buy a Michigan apple over an organic Washinton apple any day.

    Ol Drippy21167

  • LoneWolfSparty said...

    Organic: Grown in poo

    Like usual, you're a sensationalist, babbling idiot on this topic.

    From wiki:

    "Animal dung has been used for centuries as a fertilizer for farming, as it improves the soil structure (aggregation), so that it holds more nutrients and water, and becomes more fertile. Animal manure also encourages soil microbial activity, which promotes the soil's trace mineral supply, improving plant nutrition. It also contains some nitrogen and other nutrients that assist the growth of plants."

    From OTA:

    "Both conventional and organic agriculture utilize manure as part of regular farm soil fertilization programs."

    This post was edited by The Pantry on 4/12/2012 at 6:31 PM

    Manure Facts - Organic Trade Association

    http://www.ota.com/organic/foodsafety/manure.html

    www.ota.com

    The Pantry

  • DavidsonNCCock said...

    what the eff (to the pic)?

    Bully whippet. Naturally occurring myostatin mutation causes the condition. While they're super muscular, they actually have awful endurance.

    In other news, if you have no idea how genetically modified plants are made, and what it actually means to have a genetically modified plant, your opinion is worth nothing. It's depressing the number of people who don't know a thing about genetics yet protest GM food.

    Mayleman

  • Thepostmen said...

    The question was is it worth it. I'd say it depends on what you mean by organic. Organic food from meijer; you might as well just buy the non-organic stuff. But, what are you buying this food for? Let me answer, you're buying it for THE TASTE. MSU is a school with a lot of farmers. Buddy up to one of them, and have them serve you a steak from one of their cows, with some of the tomatos that they grew. Now that stuff is worth it. Or even the MSU food Co-op, go buy something from their stand and tell me it doesn't taste better than what you would get at meijer. So I say, if you want to serve up a really delicous meal every once in a while, going the extra mile to get the real stuff is worth it.

    My 6 year old can tell the difference between "farmer's market food" and "store food". Organic food from the farmer's market tastes better to him. There is a huge difference. Organic farms are not being subsidized like the mass chemically enhanced production, and that plays a huge role in the price hike. Here is plenty of lobbying to keep it that way for the time being. Doing something the right way is never easy or economically attractive. The organic producers operate on much smaller margins but provide a higher quality product. The money you save on cheap and compromised food now will multiply ten fold in your medical expenses later. There is no such thing as cheap quality food.

    signature image

    Online Predator