Online Now 3737

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 2993
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 3882
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

Maybe Kentucky isn't actually cheating...

  • just gaming a really really stupid system.

    shrug

    JMCSpartan08

  • If by gaming you mean cheating then yes, they are gaming the system.

    signature image

    December 3, 2011 - Forever haunted by what I witnessed...

    Uncle NitNots

  • You mean the NCAA institutionalized Cal's cheating by requiring one-and-dones?

    Sparty is our mascot, we are Spartans.

    ConQueso

  • Give or take Davis' for sale, $200K going once, twice...

    Larry Kazamias

  • Whether UK and Cal are cheating right now or not (I'm gonna safely assume they are), they both have cheated multiple times in the past. I have little respect for Kentucky and/or Cal and will not root for them.

    MSUsbetterthanu

  • The system is definitely flawed. Currently a player only has to remain eligible for 1 semester. He can quit going to classes after Christmas and the NCAA won't find out until he gets his report card well after the season ends. By then, he's already cashing his agent's advance.

    Having said that, lots of schools are gaming that system and they are not getting the talent that Kentucky is.

    David Giard

  • Yeah.

    And maybe I'll come home someday to see Jennifer Love Hewitt in my bed waiting for me.

    Don't laugh.

    It's possible.

    attachment
    signature image signature image signature image

    FREE YOUR BREASTS! FREE YOUR MIND!

    Archangel

  • This 1 and done, let Kentucky buy players non-sense has ruined CBB for me.

    I hate the fact that everybody know's their cheating, but none of the networks want to expose it, because of the conflict of interest, due to the huge television contracts.

    Kentucky just magically gets the top 2-3 NBA picks, every year, in a corrupt system, for free?

    The Matador

  • attachment

    "We'll play anyone, anyplace, anytime!" - Tom Izzo

    ToxSpartan

  • If they really just stop going to class Jan 1, then the rules about progress toward graduation will catch up with them. Cal says all his guys have finished the semester and claims UK has the highest APR in the SEC.

    Thought it was interesting in the Rome interview with Calipari and Pitino yesterday, Rick compared the job Cal has done with Tark's UNLV and Calhoun at UConn (two of the biggest cheaters around).

    This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by WBill19542 on 4/1/2012 at 8:57 AM

    WBill19542

  • Serious question ... I read the no classes after Jan 1 thing but that is technically not against the rules. So can someone explain how exactly they are 'cheating'?

    DCSpartan

  • David Giard said...

    The system is definitely flawed. Currently a player only has to remain eligible for 1 semester. He can quit going to classes after Christmas and the NCAA won't find out until he gets his report card well after the season ends. By then, he's already cashing his agent's advance.

    Having said that, lots of schools are gaming that system and they are not getting the talent that Kentucky is.

    They don't pay as well as Kentucky does.

    Posting member of tRCMB since 1997. It is ALWAYS a great day to be a Spartan!!!!

    Raytooth Morgan

  • WBill@ said...
    ..., then the rules about progress toward graduation will catch up with them. Cal says all his guys have finished the semester and claims UK has the highest APR in the SEC.

    Thought it was interesting in the Rome interview with Calipari and Pitino yesterday, Rick compared the job Cal has done with Tark's UNLV and Calhoun at UConn (two of the biggest cheaters around).

    Isn't there an exception if a player goes pro? Otherwise Ky is going to lose all of their schollies sometime soon.

    And let's see: How many times has Ky been caught cheating? How many schools has Cal left just before the investigations? Everyone knows Ky is cheating and paying either players or families but nobody can prove it or everyone is keeping their mouth shut.

    The networks are never going to say anything because of the money and the NCAA will not sacrifice their MONEY COW until the public stops watching the tournament. So, from now on don't watch and let the NCAA know about it.

    Nίκη για MSU

    Bender

  • DCSpartan said...

    Serious question ... I read the no classes after Jan 1 thing but that is technically not against the rules. So can someone explain how exactly they are 'cheating'?

    It's been alleged that Davis took $200K to attend Kentucky, it was a story a while back, but they media has swept it under the rug for now. There are also allegedly other violations specifically in Anthony Davis's recruitment.

    Outside of that, Kentucky fields 6 picks in the next NBA draft including 5 1st rounders and likely the top 2 picks in Michal KG and Davis. It just doesn't add up to some people.

    Johnny2x2x

  • In my view, it all really comes down to what you call "cheating." Kentucky does recruit one-and-dones, Calipari has a history of NCAA infractions at his programs with seasons and NCAA appearances vacated at Mass and Memphis, there has been tons of smoke regarding the recruitment of Davis, etc. We'll likely see Calipari move on before anything surfaces at Kentucky. I doubt the program is clean, but to what degree they're taking advantage of a system or flat-out cheating is the great unknown.

    The real issue, to me, is the Kentucky fanbase who seems very willing to trade integrity for titles. In college football and basketball, it's very difficult to run a clean program and compete at that elite level for national titles. Fanbases tend to be willing to pretend it's not happening at their school despite the signs and symptoms. There is just too much money and pressure to win at some of these schools and that inevitably leads to coaching staffs looking for ways to shortcut the system. Kentucky knew this when they hired Calipari and they didn't care because they would be winning titles. Selling your soul, even a little bit, just doesn't seem worth it to me.......

    "An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind." --Gandhi

    Heathens 87

  • Heathens '87 said...

    Selling your soul, even a little bit, just doesn't seem worth it to me.......

    But, but, but...he seems like such a nice guy!

    Signed,

    Jack Passion

    "RCMB: You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainry." - some dude from MgoBlog

    JEK

  • Maybe Brady Hoke isn't actually fat

    TravisotCosmos

  • I agree with Heathens. If MSU suddenly started running a program like Cal is, any championships would feel empty (and in all likelihood end up literally empty). You wouldn't get a chance to see any good players develop into great players, and if you do, they would all be an afterthought to the lottery picks. No players like Draymond or even Suton, who worked their asses off and became key players on championship-caliber teams. Also you'd know that the entire country hated you, not only for winning but also how you're winning. I'd be embarrassed by that.

    ARW Lasers20025

  • A.R.W. Lasers said...

    I agree with Heathens. If MSU suddenly started running a program like Cal is, any championships would feel empty (and in all likelihood end up literally empty). You wouldn't get a chance to see any good players develop into great players, and if you do, they would all be an afterthought to the lottery picks. No players like Draymond or even Suton, who worked their asses off and became key players on championship-caliber teams. Also you'd know that the entire country hated you, not only for winning but also how you're winning. I'd be embarrassed by that.

    I would hope that all Spartans would be ashamed if we used cheating to win a championship.

    I still hear Michigan fans bragging about the Fab Five era all the time though. This was arguably the largest scandal in NCAA history and fans from a supposedly integrity laden school are still touting this era.

    In my experience, where there is smoke there is fire. It was true of Michigan Basketball in the 90s, it was true of USC football, Ohio State Football, Miami Football, Memphis Basketball etc etc These schools are supposed to be competing on an even playing field for recruits, when one school is getting literally 3 or 4 of the best 10 players every season to come to Kentucky (Kentucky?) and there is a vast history of cheating at both the school and with the coach there is about as much smoke as you can have.

    This proves the NCAA is a joke, they are protecting programs like Kentucky because they are in it for the money. If the NCAA were serious about enforcement there would be guys there whose "Spidey Sense" would be going nuts right now. It just doesn't add up. You would think that a dozen recruits who were leaning towards other schools then visit and commit to Michigan after 1 visit would raise some red flags too, but it's all about the TV contracts to the NCAA.

    Now some people have said, well, what about Carolina? Well, yeah, they get close to the same level of talent that UK does, but it's a historically clean program with aa cleaner coach and it's a more prestigious program. Carolina Basketball is an institution.

    Johnny2x2x

  • Technically they aren't cheating if the players meet NCAA qualifications for eligibility as freshman, they attend classes, complete the first semester, attend some classes, complete some class work and return to campus after the tournament. Its all within current NCAA eligibility rules.

    A few years ago the NCAA did penalize UCLA softball when the found their star pitcher from Australia had enrolled in 2nd semester classes but never attended any and flew directly from the NCAA finals in Oklahoma City back home to Austrailia.

    Calipari and his staff are experts on NCAA rules so that won't happen.

    We are probably cryiing over spilled milk since many think Calipari will be caoching in the NBA next year if Kentucky wins Monday.

    GRR Spartan

  • Does Cal even recruit these guys hard or does World Wide Wes just funnel them to UK ?

    WBill19542

  • The Matador said...

    This 1 and done, let Kentucky buy players non-sense has ruined CBB for me.

    I hate the fact that everybody know's their cheating, but none of the networks want to expose it, because of the conflict of interest, due to the huge television contracts.

    Kentucky just magically gets the top 2-3 NBA picks, every year, in a corrupt system, for free?

    Moreover, somehow coach Cal was able to do it when his predecesors could not at UK. He also was able to do it at Memphis , yes, Memphis. For some reason Memphis was unable to draw people after he left?

    Patlanta

  • WBill@ said...

    Does Cal even recruit these guys hard or does World Wide Wes just funnel them to UK ?

    Rexrode came a sentence or two away from writing about cal's "recruitment methods" and what several straight-up coaches, including Izzo, had to say about it not too long ago. It almost boiled over a summer or two ago, when uk signed a bunch of 5 star players at once, despite cal being nowhere around them all summer on the circuit, where most every other college coach in America was, and was watching these kids and the people around them and what was happening.

    There have been prices attached to many of his kids for years in the rumor mill, not often the rumor mill actually continually comes up with that detailed a rumor.

    And btw, the "they recruit one-and-done" players....everyone does that. uk just wins that battle constantly because of WWW.

    This post was edited by mentalstate on 4/1/2012 at 11:03 AM

    mentalstate

  • mentalstate said...

    Rexrode came a sentence or two away from writing about cal's "recruitment methods" and what several straight-up coaches, including Izzo, had to say about it not too long ago. It almost boiled over a summer or two ago, when uk signed a bunch of 5 star players at once, despite cal being nowhere around them all summer on the circuit, where most every other college coach in America was, and was watching these kids and the people around them and what was happening.

    There have been prices attached to many of his kids for years in the rumor mill, not often the rumor mill actually continually comes up with that detailed a rumor.

    And btw, the "they recruit one-and-done" players....everyone does that. uk just wins that battle constantly because of WWW.

    Don't forget the $hoe companie$ that are supplying the grea$e.

    GRR Spartan

  • mentalstate said...

    Rexrode came a sentence or two away from writing about cal's "recruitment methods" and what several straight-up coaches, including Izzo, had to say about it not too long ago. It almost boiled over a summer or two ago, when uk signed a bunch of 5 star players at once, despite cal being nowhere around them all summer on the circuit, where most every other college coach in America was, and was watching these kids and the people around them and what was happening.

    There have been prices attached to many of his kids for years in the rumor mill, not often the rumor mill actually continually comes up with that detailed a rumor.

    And btw, the "they recruit one-and-done" players....everyone does that. uk just wins that battle constantly because of WWW.

    How can it not be some kind of violation for WWW to even commnicate just once with a potantial recruit, he's basically an agent? Just read up on him a little, this is the exact type of guy that should not be anywhere near College Basketball in any way. He's got roots going back 20 years, how could the NCAA let him hang around a porgram like Kentucky? I mean it's just preposterous!!! Worse than Ed Martin.

    This post was edited by Johnny2x2x on 4/1/2012 at 11:14 AM

    Johnny2x2x