Online Now 2283

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 1797
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 2458
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

Most underacheiving team in Detroit sports history

  • Spartan8Ball said...

    Laird is not close to VMart . You're forced to play Avila hurt because Laird can't consistently hit.

    Laird will end up batting .250, don't worry. VMart will spot catch next year.

    Martinez barely caught last year.

    I'll be stunned if he catches another game coming off ACL surgery.

    Was Laird acquired prior to Martinez's injury?

    Anyone. Anyplace. Anytime.

    rookmsu

  • Ol' Drippy said...

    Haha well I guess I'm still techically correct because I said "none that I follow" and I"ve never heard of a single one of those guys. (5 appear to be associated with ESPN which I literally never watch unless it's a clip posted on this site.)

    Looking at that link you posted I think i counted about 5 out of 50. More than I thought but still not any kindof overwhelming favorite.

    Haha, fair enough. But you have to know who John Kruk is, right?

    Fat guy, one testicle, almost got hit in the head with a Randy Johnson fastball in an all star game and turned his helmet around backward. Doesn't ring a bell?

    Ringer23

  • Spartan8Ball said...

    Laird is not close to VMart . You're forced to play Avila hurt because Laird can't consistently hit.

    Laird will end up batting .250, don't worry. VMart will spot catch next year.

    No way...at least not enough to give Avila adequate rest, making carrying another backup catcher necessary and further reducing the need for Vmart ever to catch again.

    This post was edited by WBill19542 on 6/3/2012 at 8:10 PM

    WBill19542

  • .120 team avg. with the bases loaded is absurd. Beyond absurd.

    ByTor20084

  • By-Tor said...

    .120 team avg. with the bases loaded is absurd. Beyond absurd.

    Yeah, when someone comes up with the bases loaded, they usually flash his career BA in that situation, typically its way north of .300. Yet the team is .120 this year.

    This post was edited by WBill19542 on 6/3/2012 at 8:13 PM

    WBill19542

  • By-Tor said...

    .120 team avg. with the bases loaded is absurd. Beyond absurd.

    Just atrocious. Do you know the average with runners in scoring position?

    spartans17

  • spartans17 said...

    Just atrocious. Do you know the average with runners in scoring position?

    It was ranked 4th as of yesterday.

    Anyone. Anyplace. Anytime.

    rookmsu

  • spartans17 said...

    Just atrocious. Do you know the average with runners in scoring position?

    5th right now in the majors with a .281 average...

    2012 MLB Team Batting Stats - Major League Baseball - ESPN

    Discover the 2012 MLB team statistics leaders for Batting

    espn.go.com

    Ringer23

  • I dunno, what year did the lions lose like 5-2 to Dallas in the playoffs? I was a kid but remember major disappointment at steamany thought could win it all. Maybe I'm goin senile.

    signature image signature image signature image

    DWags

  • rookmsu said...

    Martinez barely caught last year.

    I'll be stunned if he catches another game coming off ACL surgery.

    Was Laird acquired prior to Martinez's injury?

    He won't catch this year. If this was 1995 I would agree with you. Surgery and rehab has come a long way the past few decades. He caught 26 games last year. I can see him catching around the same amount next year with a whole off season to work with. We need a solid backup for Avila. He caught alot of games last year. I think the long season is taking the toll on him now.

    Having Vmart as the backup catcher can open up an additional roster spot. You don't have to waste the spot on Santos or Laird.

    This post was edited by Spartan8Ball on 6/3/2012 at 8:59 PM

    signature image

    Spartan8Ball

  • Spartan8Ball said...

    He won't catch this year. If this was 1995 I would agree with you. Surgery and rehab has come a long way the past few decades. He caught 26 games last year. I can see him catching around the same amount next year with a whole off season to work with. We need a solid backup for Avila. He caught alot of games last year. I think the long season is taking the toll on him now.

    Laird was signed as the backup catcher in November.

    Martinez was injured in January. Martinez wasn't going to catch this year.

    Tigers confirm signing Gerald Laird as backup catcher

    http://www.wxyz.com/dpp/sports/baseball/tigers/tigers-reportedly-bring-back-gerald-laird-as-backup-catcher

    www.wxyz.com

    Anyone. Anyplace. Anytime.

    rookmsu

  • 99-01 red wings was hard. I almost accept the loss to the avs in 2000 but 99I was dominant team coming home with 2-0you lead on avs and 01 first round loss to the kings was awful.

    LP

  • The 1995 or 1996 Wings could be near the top of that list, they steamrolled both years (especially 1996) and choked out in the playoffs.

    signature image signature image

    L.G.R.W.

    beal99

  • My ADD is kicking in so I'm not gonna read all the responses but my rational brain says we've still got a looooooong way to go before this season is over. And I know this is a "hypothetical" scenario as stated, assuming that they continue to tank, but I don't believe it's going to happen. The team has holes, so does every other team in the fucking league. They also have 2 of the top 3-4 players in the game, a lot of talent elsewhere, and playoff experience. They aren't going to play like this all year. Water usually finds its level.

    All that said, I get as frustrated as anyone else....they are just fucking brutal to watch at least half the time.

    No one is going to run away with this division and the Tigers will play better than they have. Doesn't mean they'll be in the ALCS again, but you're letting the frustration of watching them underperform to date go to your head if you think they're going to finish 12 games under .500 or whatever.

    Knibb High football rules

    WhiteBoyHatcher

  • rookmsu said...

    Laird was signed as the backup catcher in November.

    Martinez was injured in January. Martinez wasn't going to catch this year.

    I think he was insurance if Avila or VMart got injured. You have to remember Avila caught alot last year. Leyland gave him 26 off days last year. He has 10+ this year already. Leyland wore him out last year.

    This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by Spartan8Ball on 6/3/2012 at 9:05 PM

    signature image

    Spartan8Ball

  • Spartan8Ball said...

    I think he was insurance if Avila or VMart got injured. You have to remember Avila caught alot last year. Leyland gave him 26 off days last year. He has 10+ this year already.

    I hear you, but Martinez is now a full-time DH. He may have been the emergency catcher, but Laird was signed as the primary backup catcher.

    Martinez wasn't a particularly good catcher his last two years in Cleveland. He's a designated hitter.

    Anyone. Anyplace. Anytime.

    rookmsu

  • Some of those Lions teams with Barry.

    ErnieMcCracken

  • WhiteBoyHatcher said...

    My ADD is kicking in so I'm not gonna read all the responses but my rational brain says we've still got a looooooong way to go before this season is over. And I know this is a "hypothetical" scenario as stated, assuming that they continue to tank, but I don't believe it's going to happen. The team has holes, so does every other team in the fucking league. They also have 2 of the top 3-4 players in the game, a lot of talent elsewhere, and playoff experience. They aren't going to play like this all year. Water usually finds its level.

    All that said, I get as frustrated as anyone else....they are just fucking brutal to watch at least half the time.

    No one is going to run away with this division and the Tigers will play better than they have. Doesn't mean they'll be in the ALCS again, but you're letting the frustration of watching them underperform to date go to your head if you think they're going to finish 12 games under .500 or whatever.

    I guess my biggest frustration with them is that there is little that one can point to and say, "this one thing must change in order for us to get better". It's just bad across the board. Hitters aren't hitting in the right moments, fielders are fucking up and playing lazy, relievers are letting in runs at inopportune times, pitchers are having uncharacteristically bad games, and the overall players are just making some very poor judgment calls (all the baserunning mistakes for instance). It's early June, and it feels like the team is on the ropes already and they're playing like it. You can tell how badly they want to break out but it's just setback after setback. I don't know, I don't get the feeling that there's a monster underneath this cover; it just feels like they'll be mediocre/flirting with .500 all year.

    spartans17

  • spartans17 said...

    I guess my biggest frustration with them is that there is little that one can point to and say, "this one thing must change in order for us to get better". It's just bad across the board. Hitters aren't hitting in the right moments, fielders are fucking up and playing lazy, relievers are letting in runs at inopportune times, pitchers are having uncharacteristically bad games, and the overall players are just making some very poor judgment calls (all the baserunning mistakes for instance). It's early June, and it feels like the team is on the ropes already and they're playing like it. You can tell how badly they want to break out but it's just setback after setback. I don't know, I don't get the feeling that there's a monster underneath this cover; it just feels like they'll be mediocre/flirting with .500 all year.

    Agree to some extent. But I would say that the "one thing" that you can point to is the hitting.

    We knew they were going to be terrible on defense and on the basepaths. We knew the bullpen would be mediocre and the SP outside of JV and Fister was going to be mediocre. We also were fooling ourselves if we thought that now that JV had finally made himself "elite", he was going to repeat his 2011 year annually, and if we thought that Fister was going to win 87% of his starts with a 1.3 ERA or whatever. Still, all those things considered, the lineup hits like they should and they power through many of those other shortcomings.

    The bullpen is actually starting to take shape (outside of Valverde) and you also have to take injuries into consideration.

    In short, everything has been pretty much as expected minus the injuries and the bats. And the bats won't stay silent forever. Do we really think Prince is only going to hit solo HRs for the rest of the year?

    Knibb High football rules

    WhiteBoyHatcher

  • WhiteBoyHatcher said...

    Agree to some extent. But I would say that the "one thing" that you can point to is the hitting.

    We knew they were going to be terrible on defense and on the basepaths. We knew the bullpen would be mediocre and the SP outside of JV and Fister was going to be mediocre. We also were fooling ourselves if we thought that now that JV had finally made himself "elite", he was going to repeat his 2011 year annually, and if we thought that Fister was going to win 87% of his starts with a 1.3 ERA or whatever. Still, all those things considered, the lineup hits like they should and they power through many of those other shortcomings.

    The bullpen is actually starting to take shape (outside of Valverde) and you also have to take injuries into consideration.

    In short, everything has been pretty much as expected minus the injuries and the bats. And the bats won't stay silent forever. Do we really think Prince is only going to hit solo HRs for the rest of the year?

    Well, one point of view would say that Prince will continue to hit solo HRs if no one is getting on base in front of him. Outside of Prince and Miggy, there isn't much that one can REALLY expect from the rest of the lineup. Take a look at it up and down and tell me who you truly expect to break out based on pedigree:

    Jackson: hitting way above his talent-level; this will drop
    Dirks: same as above; his average will probably settle in the .270-.280 range (which I'd be happy with)
    Berry: same, although I expect him to be around .240 or .250 if he gets enough ABs
    Boesch: hitting poorly, but outside of a couple of months, he hasn't hit THAT well in his big league career for us to expect huge things
    Peralta: hitting poorly and his average should rise; still, last year was an anomaly and he may hit .250 all year
    Avila: can't really expect the same year as last year; not enough of a sample size to truly say that he's been hitting poorly this year
    Kelly and Santiago: not much you can expect from them
    Young: hitting is up to .260 now, not much more you can expect

    Now, if Jackson, Berry and Dirks continue to get on, and Peralta/Boesch/Avila can increase their average a bit, then we'd have something.

    spartans17

  • WhiteBoyHatcher said...

    Agree to some extent. But I would say that the "one thing" that you can point to is the hitting.

    We knew they were going to be terrible on defense and on the basepaths. We knew the bullpen would be mediocre and the SP outside of JV and Fister was going to be mediocre. We also were fooling ourselves if we thought that now that JV had finally made himself "elite", he was going to repeat his 2011 year annually, and if we thought that Fister was going to win 87% of his starts with a 1.3 ERA or whatever. Still, all those things considered, the lineup hits like they should and they power through many of those other shortcomings.

    The bullpen is actually starting to take shape (outside of Valverde) and you also have to take injuries into consideration.

    In short, everything has been pretty much as expected minus the injuries and the bats. And the bats won't stay silent forever. Do we really think Prince is only going to hit solo HRs for the rest of the year?

    The issue is 5-9. For all we know they are hitting like they should.

    ByTor20084

  • long way to go guys

    08 Tigers
    05 Lions(team had some talent)
    02-03 Wings
    03-04 Wings
    05-06 Wings

    Spartan Dawgs20

  • D.Wags said...

    I dunno, what year did the lions lose like 5-2 to Dallas in the playoffs? I was a kid but remember major disappointment at steamany thought could win it all. Maybe I'm goin senile.

    It was the1970 season. Lions lost to Dallas in the opening round 5-0. Lions QB Greg Landry was a jangle of nerves and was just swallowed up whole by the moment. The Lions had won 5 straight to finally make the playoffs, the defense comes up huge, and the offense just disappeared. Very disappointing.

    For me I think the 1969 Tigers are right up there as most disappointing considering they came off a World's Championship the year before and returned virtually the same team. It was the first season of division play and they were never in it finishing 19 games back despite winning 90 games and having Denny McLain win 24 and being co-winner of the Cy Young following his 31 win Cy Young season in 1968. The Orioles were unbelieveably good that year but ran into the Miracle Mets and lost the World Series despite being heavy favorites to win it.

    "I'm going to be a coach here for a long time. It's not over. It'll never be over. It's just starting." - Mark Dantonio

    SpartyHardy

  • Detroit loves college sports, so I'm going with the 2007 Michigan Wolverines.

    Started the preseason ranked in the Top 5 and viewed as a national title contender. Immediately lost to Appalachian State. lol

    signature image

    Giant Moose

  • if you include MSU as Detroit sports, how can you say the Tigers are underacheiving more than the 2002 MSU Spartan football team? Darkhorse candidate for National Championship by Mark May, ranked 18 in both polls to start season, we ended up 4-8 and fired our coach.

    Spartan Punk