Online Now 3089

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 2251
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 3113
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

Webb May Soon Visit MSU Again

  • EZMAC said...

    ..... or the fanbase any favors by playing a guy simply because he's paid dues.

    So MD should do a survey of the fanbase to see who startslol

    Ron_in_ATL

  • Awink2 said...

    Cemented what fact? That our 2 starting CB's were our for the game, or that the team will not be fully complete with elite starters and depth from top to bottom who were actually recruited by this staff for another 2-3 years.

    Don't forget the guy that got hurt against Bama

    This post was edited by Ron_in_ATL on 1/3/2013 at 7:09 AM

    Ron_in_ATL

  • Awink2 said...

    Cemented what fact? That our 2 starting CB's were our for the game, or that the team will not be fully complete with elite starters and depth from top to bottom who were actually recruited by this staff for another 2-3 years.

    The cupboard is bare. lol

    Your secondary was exposed against Bama and a running team in South Carolina. It was highly ranked because the Big Ten sucked on offense this year.

    scimini

  • Awink2 said...

    Cemented what fact? That our 2 starting CB's were our for the game, or that the team will not be fully complete with elite starters and depth from top to bottom who were actually recruited by this staff for another 2-3 years.

    It seems like every year we hear this whole " 2 to 3 years" shit from you guys....You make it sound like Dick Rod brought in a bunch of scrubs. I don't get it.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Respert 4 Three

  • Awink2 said...

    Cemented what fact? That our 2 starting CB's were our for the game, or that the team will not be fully complete with elite starters and depth from top to bottom who were actually recruited by this staff for another 2-3 years.

    Elite talent? RichRod brought in two back to back top 10 classes. And every year Michigan had at least a top 20 class.

    Just another 2-3 years.... RECRUUUUUUUTING.

    LOL. You guys are hysterical.

    dagomike

  • Awink2 said...

    Cemented what fact? That our 2 starting CB's were our for the game, or that the team will not be fully complete with elite starters and depth from top to bottom who were actually recruited by this staff for another 2-3 years.

    UM's best chance to win the B1G -- and by a wide margin -- was this year. But whenever UM plays a decent team, or plays on the road, it chokes. You know this is true. OSU will continue to dominate UM, and UM doesn't get to beat up on John L. or Bobby Williams anymore.

    And maybe worthy of its own thread, is the myth UM fans perpetuate about how Rich Rod "destroyed" the program. Certainly, he was a better offensive coach than anyone currently at UM. And his recruiting was excellent. Here's a trip down memory lane of how Rich Rod "destroyed" UM:

    - Elliot Mealer: 4* recruit
    - Brandon Smith: 4*
    - Brandon Moore: 4*
    - Dann O’Neill: 4*
    - Kevin Koger: 4*
    - Roy Roundtree: 4*
    - Mike Martin: 4*
    - Ricky Barnum: 4*

    And that's just his first year....the next year he "destroyed" UM with garbage like

    - William Campbell: 5*
    - Taylor Lewan: 4*/5*
    - Je’Ron Stokes: 4*
    - Craig Roh: 4*
    - Jeremy Gallon: 4* (remember, small WRs hurt a team...just ask South Carolina)
    - Quinton Washington:4*
    - UM's greatest offensive player of all time - Denard Robinson: 4*

    Then Rich Rod completely nuked your program, by insulting it with guys like Devin Gardner: 4*(the guy UM is now in love with) and Richard Ash: yet another 4* D guy.

    All years but one, Rich Rod has a top-ten rated recruiting class. And we know UM fans love them some rankings between the months of February and September. And 4 star recruits are a guarantee that the future is bright -- I mean, look at that star glitter above. I feel like Carl Sagan looking at that stuff.

    3* hacks like Jake Ryan, JT Floyd, Jibreel Black -- again, all Rich Rod program wreckers -- should never have been offered. I'd try to go one, but its hard to find more three stars among all the 4 stars.

    So...I'm absolutely positive UM's current 4* recruits are better than the past 4* recruits, and the zero-sum game of recruiting must result in MSU having less. I know that line makes UM fans feel good.

    One-half of a championship since WWII says it all. I know you guys compiled big stats at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, and resided at or near the top of the B1G ten for a long time (then Bo would fall on his face as soon as he played outside the conference).

    MSU had a bad year, and I readily admit it. But we did beat the SEC East champ last year.

    Tupes

  • Tupes said...

    UM's best chance to win the B1G -- and by a wide margin -- was this year. But whenever UM plays a decent team, or plays on the road, it chokes. You know this is true. OSU will continue to dominate UM, and UM doesn't get to beat up on John L. or Bobby Williams anymore.

    And maybe worthy of its own thread, is the myth UM fans perpetuate about how Rich Rod "destroyed" the program. Certainly, he was a better offensive coach than anyone currently at UM. And his recruiting was excellent. Here's a trip down memory lane of how Rich Rod "destroyed" UM:

    - Elliot Mealer: 4* recruit - Brandon Smith: 4* - Brandon Moore: 4* - Dann O’Neill: 4* - Kevin Koger: 4* - Roy Roundtree: 4* - Mike Martin: 4* - Ricky Barnum: 4*

    And that's just his first year....the next year he "destroyed" UM with garbage like

    - William Campbell: 5* - Taylor Lewan: 4*/5* - Je’Ron Stokes: 4* - Craig Roh: 4* - Jeremy Gallon: 4* (remember, small WRs hurt a team...just ask South Carolina) - Quinton Washington:4* - UM's greatest offensive player of all time - Denard Robinson: 4*

    Then Rich Rod completely nuked your program, by insulting it with guys like Devin Gardner: 4*(the guy UM is now in love with) and Richard Ash: yet another 4* D guy.

    All years but one, Rich Rod has a top-ten rated recruiting class. And we know UM fans love them some rankings between the months of February and September. And 4 star recruits are a guarantee that the future is bright -- I mean, look at that star glitter above. I feel like Carl Sagan looking at that stuff.

    3* hacks like Jake Ryan, JT Floyd, Jibreel Black -- again, all Rich Rod program wreckers -- should never have been offered. I'd try to go one, but its hard to find more three stars among all the 4 stars.

    So...I'm absolutely positive UM's current 4* recruits are better than the past 4* recruits, and the zero-sum game of recruiting must result in MSU having less. I know that line makes UM fans feel good.

    One-half of a championship since WWII says it all. I know you guys compiled big stats at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, and resided at or near the top of the B1G ten for a long time (then Bo would fall on his face as soon as he played outside the conference).

    MSU had a bad year, and I readily admit it. But we did beat the SEC East champ last year.

    Oneil, Smith, and Stokes all transferred out while Rodriguez was the coach, so im not sure what your trying to get at. Michigan's defensive backfield against South Carolina consists of a Walk on in Kovacs(Overacheiver, but not good enough against elite teams), 3star Thomas Gordon, 3star Raymon Taylor(4star on one site rivals), 3star Courtney Avery. Where is this myth coming from that Michigan is "loaded" with talent especially in the defensive backfield, if anything that group overachieved given the fact we had no pass rush and our best CB got injured the first game of the season. You can clearly see when Michigan plays that they are not "loaded with talent", they have very few if any playmakers on defense. I don't put stock into anything Rodriguez did especially on the defensive side of the football except destroy the program and ruin the careers of kid's like Will Campbell, Craig Roh, etc... Would have love to have seen how the FEW highly rated guys he did bring in on the defensive side of the football would have developed with Mattison in charge for their full 4 years. Recruiting is not about star ratings im sure a well educated spartan like yourself knows that. It's about identifying high level players who fit your system and then developing them once they get on campus. I feel a hell of alot more confident in Hoke and Mattison getting that done, then what Rodriguez ever did. This year was a failure no doubt, just gotta come back stronger next year and I think they will.

    TheDudeAbides21

  • Tupes said...

    UM's best chance to win the B1G -- and by a wide margin -- was this year. But whenever UM plays a decent team, or plays on the road, it chokes. You know this is true. OSU will continue to dominate UM, and UM doesn't get to beat up on John L. or Bobby Williams anymore.

    And maybe worthy of its own thread, is the myth UM fans perpetuate about how Rich Rod "destroyed" the program. Certainly, he was a better offensive coach than anyone currently at UM. And his recruiting was excellent. Here's a trip down memory lane of how Rich Rod "destroyed" UM:

    - Elliot Mealer: 4* recruit - Brandon Smith: 4* - Brandon Moore: 4* - Dann O’Neill: 4* - Kevin Koger: 4* - Roy Roundtree: 4* - Mike Martin: 4* - Ricky Barnum: 4*

    And that's just his first year....the next year he "destroyed" UM with garbage like

    - William Campbell: 5* - Taylor Lewan: 4*/5* - Je’Ron Stokes: 4* - Craig Roh: 4* - Jeremy Gallon: 4* (remember, small WRs hurt a team...just ask South Carolina) - Quinton Washington:4* - UM's greatest offensive player of all time - Denard Robinson: 4*

    Then Rich Rod completely nuked your program, by insulting it with guys like Devin Gardner: 4*(the guy UM is now in love with) and Richard Ash: yet another 4* D guy.

    All years but one, Rich Rod has a top-ten rated recruiting class. And we know UM fans love them some rankings between the months of February and September. And 4 star recruits are a guarantee that the future is bright -- I mean, look at that star glitter above. I feel like Carl Sagan looking at that stuff.

    3* hacks like Jake Ryan, JT Floyd, Jibreel Black -- again, all Rich Rod program wreckers -- should never have been offered. I'd try to go one, but its hard to find more three stars among all the 4 stars.

    So...I'm absolutely positive UM's current 4* recruits are better than the past 4* recruits, and the zero-sum game of recruiting must result in MSU having less. I know that line makes UM fans feel good.

    One-half of a championship since WWII says it all. I know you guys compiled big stats at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, and resided at or near the top of the B1G ten for a long time (then Bo would fall on his face as soon as he played outside the conference).

    MSU had a bad year, and I readily admit it. But we did beat the SEC East champ last year.

    My God, Tupes....you just blew UM fan boy out of the water.

    signature image

    Hank Moody

  • TheDudeAbides21 said...

    I feel a hell of alot more confident in Hoke and Mattison getting that done, then what Rodriguez ever did. This year was a failure no doubt, just gotta come back stronger next year and I think they will.

    Fair points... Mattison much >>>>> Greg Robinson. And system fit, development, all that....is key I agree. Star gazing, however, is the wrong activity for UM fans hoping that 2016 -- or whenever UM is supposed to be "back." Because its pretty starry back in the Rich Rod era too.

    Tupes

  • Tupes said...

    Fair points... Mattison much >>>>> Greg Robinson. And system fit, development, all that....is key I agree. Star gazing, however, is the wrong activity for UM fans hoping that 2016 -- or whenever UM is supposed to be "back." Because its pretty starry back in the Rich Rod era too.

    If Hoke doesn't get um to tB1G championship game in the next two years, he gone.

    hoke- to alter or manipulate so as to give a deceptively or superficially improved quality or value.

    The Doctor

  • scimini said...

    The cupboard is bare. lol

    Your secondary was exposed against Bama and a running team in South Carolina. It was highly ranked because the Big Ten sucked on offense this year.

    We still managed to beat you guys, and will do so again next year.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Awink2

  • Respert 4 Three said...

    It seems like every year we hear this whole ' 2 to 3 years' shit from you guys....You make it sound like Dick Rod brought in a bunch of scrubs. I don't get it.

    If you take a look of the attrition rates from the 2009 and 2010 recruiting classes, its absurd. Over 50% of the entire 2010 class is no longer with the program. Should I elaborate more on how this affects the team with depth and quality players who are upper classman??

    signature image signature image signature image

    Awink2

  • dagomike said...

    Elite talent? RichRod brought in two back to back top 10 classes. And every year Michigan had at least a top 20 class.

    Just another 2-3 years.... RECRUUUUUUUTING.

    LOL. You guys are hysterical.

    Again, if over 50% of those kids leave within 2 years, it negates the promise of the arbitrary recruiting rankings....fortunately this is a problem of the past.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Awink2

  • Tupes said...

    UM's best chance to win the B1G -- and by a wide margin -- was this year. But whenever UM plays a decent team, or plays on the road, it chokes. You know this is true. OSU will continue to dominate UM, and UM doesn't get to beat up on John L. or Bobby Williams anymore.

    And maybe worthy of its own thread, is the myth UM fans perpetuate about how Rich Rod 'destroyed' the program. Certainly, he was a better offensive coach than anyone currently at UM. And his recruiting was excellent. Here's a trip down memory lane of how Rich Rod 'destroyed' UM:

    - Elliot Mealer: 4* recruit
    - Brandon Smith: 4*
    - Brandon Moore: 4*
    - Dann O’Neill: 4*
    - Kevin Koger: 4*
    - Roy Roundtree: 4*
    - Mike Martin: 4*
    - Ricky Barnum: 4*

    And that's just his first year....the next year he 'destroyed' UM with garbage like

    - William Campbell: 5*
    - Taylor Lewan: 4*/5*
    - Je’Ron Stokes: 4*
    - Craig Roh: 4*
    - Jeremy Gallon: 4* (remember, small WRs hurt a team...just ask South Carolina)
    - Quinton Washington:4*
    - UM's greatest offensive player of all time - Denard Robinson: 4*

    Then Rich Rod completely nuked your program, by insulting it with guys like Devin Gardner: 4*(the guy UM is now in love with) and Richard Ash: yet another 4* D guy.

    All years but one, Rich Rod has a top-ten rated recruiting class. And we know UM fans love them some rankings between the months of February and September. And 4 star recruits are a guarantee that the future is bright -- I mean, look at that star glitter above. I feel like Carl Sagan looking at that stuff.

    3* hacks like Jake Ryan, JT Floyd, Jibreel Black -- again, all Rich Rod program wreckers -- should never have been offered. I'd try to go one, but its hard to find more three stars among all the 4 stars.

    So...I'm absolutely positive UM's current 4* recruits are better than the past 4* recruits, and the zero-sum game of recruiting must result in MSU having less. I know that line makes UM fans feel good.

    One-half of a championship since WWII says it all. I know you guys compiled big stats at the dawn of the Industrial Revolution, and resided at or near the top of the B1G ten for a long time (then Bo would fall on his face as soon as he played outside the conference).

    MSU had a bad year, and I readily admit it. But we did beat the SEC East champ last year.

    12-10....your glory days are over.

    signature image signature image signature image

    Awink2

  • Awink2 said...

    12-10....your glory days are over.

    Not sure if serious about bragging over a win where UofM needed four field goals to eclipse the massive 10 points put up by MSU.

    PPTPW51983

  • PPTPW51983 said...

    Not sure if serious about bragging over a win where UofM needed four field goals to eclipse the massive 10 points put up by MSU.

    you would brag about it if it were you....I know you would

    signature image signature image signature image

    Awink2

  • You know, it's over because of 12-10 lol finally win a game and now the rivalry is one sided again typical scUM trolls.

    Being called a sunshine blower is not insulting to me and I'm proud to be one.

    SpartyFever

  • Awink2 said...

    We still managed to beat you guys, and will do so again next year.

    We? What number do/did you wear?

    Either way, still doesn't disprove the multitude of points once again showing your fan base as the whiny delusional group we all know you are.

    scimini

  • Awink2 said...

    Again, if over 50% of those kids leave within 2 years, it negates the promise of the arbitrary recruiting rankings....fortunately this is a problem of the past.

    Is it RichRod's fault that Hoke ran those guys off of the program?

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • SpartanRocky said...

    Is it RichRod's fault that Hoke ran those guys off of the program?

    Not sure why you asked this question. Not because it's an unreasonable question, but because the person you're asking is a delusional retard.

    signature image signature image

    2TimeSpartan

  • Oh, back to the point of MSU getting guys to the League, MSU is going to have a DB drafted in each of the last 4 drafts, assuming Adams gets picked

    '10 draft - Ware (Oakland)

    '11 draft - CLR (Indy)

    '12 draft - Robinson (49ers)

    '13 draft - Adams (???)

    I'd assume Dennard and Lewis stand a great chance at getting drafted in '14, and Drummond could be the next in line after that. Amazing that State had horrible DBs for about a decade.

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • Michigan is the new Notre Dame... Return to Glory! Wait til Next Year!

    KC_SPARTAN

  • SpartanRocky said...

    Oh, back to the point of MSU getting guys to the League, MSU is going to have a DB drafted in each of the last 4 drafts, assuming Adams gets picked

    '10 draft - Ware (Oakland)

    '11 draft - CLR (Indy)

    '12 draft - Robinson (49ers)

    '13 draft - Adams (???)

    I'd assume Dennard and Lewis stand a great chance at getting drafted in '14, and Drummond could be the next in line after that. Amazing that State had horrible DBs for about a decade.

    Eric Smith is still hangin' in there getting solid minutes with the Jets as well at Safety. I forgot, was he drafted or did he do what he did at MSU and try out and become a contributor? At any rate, he's another product of our Secondary from that 09' season, maybe 08'. It's been awhile.

    Skip1856

  • Awink2 said...

    We still managed to beat you guys, and will do so again next year.

    Sure, at our place without shoelaces, or possibly 4 of your starting OL to be replaced by Sophs, and without Kovacs. That 12-10 beat down you gave us while being gifted the first down and tackle of Rush on play prior clearly showed your dominance.

    mentalstate

  • Skip1856 said...

    Eric Smith is still hangin' in there getting solid minutes with the Jets as well at Safety. I forgot, was he drafted or did he do what he did at MSU and try out and become a contributor? At any rate, he's another product of our Secondary from that 09' season, maybe 08'. It's been awhile.

    Drafted in the 3rd round, but that was under JLS.

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky