Online Now 1887

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 1717
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 2273
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

Well ahead of last year's pace

  • There is no need to mention a couple of B1G schools that have gotten off to a hot start on the recruiting trail, so sorry for doing so. Coach Dantonio is well ahead of last year's pace with his fourth commit for 2013 this morning in RJ Shelton. He joins Holmes, Reschke, and Powell. The rumor mill is saying to stay tuned as another may join them.

    Last year, the Spartans didn't receive a verbal commitment until the spring game on April 30th. Three players (Bullough, Higgins, and McGowan) verballed that day and a fourth commit (Jones) was added on May 7th.

    Anyone that has an offer this early in the game is very much a Plan A recruit. Adjustments already seem to be in place to keep up with the new recruiting styles in our neighborhood. Trust in coach D, because this very well may be his best class yet.

    BigGreenHouse

  • BigGreenHouse said...

    There is no need to mention a couple of B1G schools that have gotten off to a hot start on the recruiting trail, so sorry for doing so. Coach Dantonio is well ahead of last year's pace with his fourth commit for 2013 this morning in RJ Shelton. He joins Holmes, Reschke, and Powell. The rumor mill is saying to stay tuned as another may join them.

    Last year, the Spartans didn't receive a verbal commitment until the spring game on April 30th. Three players (Bullough, Higgins, and McGowan) verballed that day and a fourth commit (Jones) was added on May 7th.

    Anyone that has an offer this early in the game is very much a Plan A recruit. Adjustments already seem to be in place to keep up with the new recruiting styles in our neighborhood. Trust in coach D, because this very well may be his best class yet.

    GREAT POST....agree 100%.......gonna be a GOOD day...I sense someone else like Norman could pop too.

    spartyon1

  • BigGreenHouse said...

    There is no need to mention a couple of B1G schools that have gotten off to a hot start on the recruiting trail, so sorry for doing so. Coach Dantonio is well ahead of last year's pace with his fourth commit for 2013 this morning in RJ Shelton. He joins Holmes, Reschke, and Powell. The rumor mill is saying to stay tuned as another may join them.

    Last year, the Spartans didn't receive a verbal commitment until the spring game on April 30th. Three players (Bullough, Higgins, and McGowan) verballed that day and a fourth commit (Jones) was added on May 7th.

    Anyone that has an offer this early in the game is very much a Plan A recruit. Adjustments already seem to be in place to keep up with the new recruiting styles in our neighborhood. Trust in coach D, because this very well may be his best class yet.

    Consider that, at most we have somewhere between 8 and 10 positions available, and its even more remarkable.

    signature image

    Dr Leo Spaceman

  • Agreed. I've seen some talk about needing a closer when we're 11 months away from signing day. Not only that, but we had one of the best closing weeks not even a month ago.

    No doubt that we're getting spoiled by this coaching staff.

    Sparty is our mascot, we are Spartans.

    ConQueso

  • I posted this list in another thread, but I think it is relevant here- no question in my mind recruiting is moving up and MSU is doing the same:

    if you look at the commitment lists of schools and look at the early top 247/250 lists, it certainly seems like things are moving faster this year. Obviously it is hard to compare because I do not have an archived list of the top prospects from this time last year, but just looking at the top 247 I see the following:

    20 of the top 50 committed

    33 of the top 100 committed

    44 of the top 150 committed

    56 of the top 200 committed

    65 of the top 247 committed

    To me that strikes me as a very very high percentage of kids already committed in February. You are looking at 40% of the top 50 players, a third of the top 100, and about a quarter of the top 247. I cannot imagine it was that high last year.

    I think you can see a difference even with MSU- As you guys said yesterday, MSU rarely has any commits this early. MSU has 3 , and could very well add a few more shortly. That would be 1/3rd of your class and only leave MSU with 8-9 open spots, if the current scholarship numbers are true.

    Big M

  • Big M said...

    I posted this list in another thread, but I think it is relevant here- no question in my mind recruiting is moving up and MSU is doing the same:

    if you look at the commitment lists of schools and look at the early top 247/250 lists, it certainly seems like things are moving faster this year. Obviously it is hard to compare because I do not have an archived list of the top prospects from this time last year, but just looking at the top 247 I see the following:

    20 of the top 50 committed

    33 of the top 100 committed

    44 of the top 150 committed

    56 of the top 200 committed

    65 of the top 247 committed

    To me that strikes me as a very very high percentage of kids already committed in February. You are looking at 40% of the top 50 players, a third of the top 100, and about a quarter of the top 247. I cannot imagine it was that high last year.

    I think you can see a difference even with MSU- As you guys said yesterday, MSU rarely has any commits this early. MSU has 3 , and could very well add a few more shortly. That would be 1/3rd of your class and only leave MSU with 8-9 open spots, if the current scholarship numbers are true.

    But... like... if we had a recruiting coordinator............

    Final Countdown

  • Big M said...

    I posted this list in another thread, but I think it is relevant here- no question in my mind recruiting is moving up and MSU is doing the same:

    if you look at the commitment lists of schools and look at the early top 247/250 lists, it certainly seems like things are moving faster this year. Obviously it is hard to compare because I do not have an archived list of the top prospects from this time last year, but just looking at the top 247 I see the following:

    20 of the top 50 committed

    33 of the top 100 committed

    44 of the top 150 committed

    56 of the top 200 committed

    65 of the top 247 committed

    To me that strikes me as a very very high percentage of kids already committed in February. You are looking at 40% of the top 50 players, a third of the top 100, and about a quarter of the top 247. I cannot imagine it was that high last year.

    I think you can see a difference even with MSU- As you guys said yesterday, MSU rarely has any commits this early. MSU has 3 , and could very well add a few more shortly. That would be 1/3rd of your class and only leave MSU with 8-9 open spots, if the current scholarship numbers are true.

    Very good info. There will always be sleepers but it looks like the top kids are being identified so much earlier because of technology, camps and kids marketing themselves through services. What used to take place in a kids Sr year is now happening in their Jr years. Every year kids are committing earlier and earlier. There are plusses and minused both for the schools and the kids. But one plus for the kid is to get it done with and enjoy their Sr year without the recruiiting pressure and spend as much time on campus attending games and getting to know your future teamates as well as help recruit the uncommitted.

    82msuspartan

  • Bump.

    7 commitments prior to the spring game.
    0 at this point in 2011

    BigGreenHouse

  • Yet BigM fails to explain how all those highly rated classes umaa has signed have failed to defeat the lower rated MSU classes 4 years in a row.

    GRR Spartan

  • GRR Spartan said...

    Yet BigM fails to explain how all those highly rated classes umaa has signed have failed to defeat the lower rated MSU classes 4 years in a row.

    Are you losing it old man? Where the heck did this post come from?

    Big M

  • For me, it doesn't matter if they commit during their freshman season or on signing day, I'm happy with Coach D getting kids that fit his system and are high ceiling players. I'm glad seven kids have already pledged their commitments but I don't think there is a pace that we really need to pay attention to, per se.

    This post was edited by ass dan on 4/16/2012 at 7:54 PM

    ass dan

  • Big M said...

    Are you losing it old man? Where the heck did this post come from?

    Fuck Michigan.....

    ass dan

  • Big M said...

    Are you losing it old man? Where the heck did this post come from?

    You do have radar on this sight.

    Losing it? No. It was a check to see how quickly you would react and it didn't take 15 minutes.

    Seems you know all about losing over the last 4 years and were posting excuses for rr all the time. Until it became so obvious even you couldn't support him. Very few posters here are constantly check blue boards. You are always over here.

    GRR Spartan

  • BigGreenHouse said...

    Bump.

    7 commitments prior to the spring game. 0 at this point in 2011

    And three four-stars.

    Our recruiting, besides being really prudent under Dantonio, is also starting to be upgraded. It was never bad, but it's getting better. This staff just gets that it's all about filling needs and building depth. We're very lucky, and we're going to be good for the foreseeable future.

    Vim -- noun: robust energy and enthusiasm : VITALITY

    Bruce Banner Ad

  • ass dan said...

    Fuck Michigan.....

    Were you trying to Embarass him with your post? If so fail. You on the other hand.

    This post was edited by bpmcgant on 4/16/2012 at 8:02 PM

    bpmcgant

  • bpmcgant said...

    Were you trying to Embarass him with your post? If so fail. You on the other hand.

    confused

    ass dan

  • Why are there scum slappies all over our board?

    Nίκη για MSU

    Bender

  • GRR Spartan said...

    You do have radar on this sight.

    Losing it? No. It was a check to see how quickly you would react and it didn't take 15 minutes.

    Seems you know all about losing over the last 4 years and were posting excuses for rr all the time. Until it became so obvious even you couldn't support him. Very few posters here are constantly check blue boards. You are always over here.

    Hook line and sinker. Congrats on your catch of the day GRR!

    YouDoubleJack

  • YouDoubleJack said...

    Hook line and sinker. Congrats on your catch of the day GRR!

    Yup, he got me. He has exposed me. It really is breaking news that I post on this board. It has been breaking news for like 15 years.

    Big M

  • Bruce Banner Ad said...

    And three four-stars.

    Our recruiting, besides being really prudent under Dantonio, is also starting to be upgraded. It was never bad, but it's getting better. This staff just gets that it's all about filling needs and building depth. We're very lucky, and we're going to be good for the foreseeable future.

    Two four-stars. Reschke and Jones. Though I really do think that Benenoch, Shelton, Terry, and Powell are all four-star talent, none of the services have them higher than three stars.

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • Id like to know who the 4 stars are? According to this site MSU has 1-4 star, Scout 1-4 star, Rivals 2-4 stars.

    bizarreagain

  • Bender said...

    Why are there scum slappies all over our board?

    inferiority complex and paranoia schizos

    SpartanHoops

  • Shut up!! lol

    ronkbacon

  • bizarreagain said...

    Id like to know who the 4 stars are? According to this site MSU has 1-4 star, Scout 1-4 star, Rivals 2-4 stars.

    You found them. Jon Reschke is consensus, Shane Jones is a four-star on Rivals. It's absolutely baffling, however, that Benenoch hasn't gotten more love. He has a four-star offer list for sure.

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • ronkbacon