Online Now 2015

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 1441
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 2137
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

Will we beat Minnesota?

  • spartan80 said...

    What signs? Dantonio saying so, MSU's 5 - 6 record, the O's constant improvement?lol

    Playing for a bowl, Minny sucks.

    Of course I thought we would be NU handily.

    spartanMF

  • Tanfan said...

    Agreed. Recruiting has been abysmal for the last two years despite back to back 11 win seasons. Now? It's nonexistent. The blowers will cheer on the next two star diamond in the rough who roushar wil coach up in a season or two.

    Honestly who don't you like in this years recruiting class?

    Reschke- stud. Looks alot like Max.
    Holmes- stud. Could end up better than Bell.
    Shelton- stud. Playmaker.
    Harris- another playmaker. tons of speed and balance.
    Terry- stud. Look at his fucking stats!
    Williams- stud. Can play anywhere.
    Hicks- stud. Plan A target since day 1.
    Finley- stud. Opened up Cass Tech. Had offers from OSU, Wisconsin. He was arguably best OL at many of the camps.
    Salmon- raw but explosive. Same thing they said about Jerel out of HS.
    Cooper- stud. Owned many of the top OL guys at camp.
    Jones- stud. Absolute beast at OLB. without questions going to be a starter on this D in a few years.
    Powell- stud. Playmaker. Most underrated guy in our class.
    Kilgore- good hands and frame. Could develop into the possession receiver this team needs.
    Chmura- don't know yet. Injured alot. But he has the potential.

    There are a few needs that we have to fill. We need to get another OL and DL guy...But you can't tell me the guys we have in the fold are not good gets.

    Look at the 14 class- all our commits are top guys. You know Harris is just going to poop on whoever tries to cover him. Another Bullough another guy from Cass with a lot of speed.

    Your gloom and doom suggests that you haven't been following recruiting as closely as a tanfan should

    This post was edited by YouDoubleJack on 11/22/2012 at 10:39 AM

    YouDoubleJack

  • YouDoubleJack said...

    Honestly who don't you like in this years recruiting class?

    Reschke- stud. Looks alot like Max.
    Holmes- stud. Could end up better than Bell.
    Shelton- stud. Playmaker.
    Terry- stud. Look at his fucking stats!
    Williams- stud. Can play anywhere.
    Hicks- stud. Plan A target since day 1.
    Finley- stud. Opened up Cass Tech. Had offers from OSU, Wisconsin. He was arguably best OL at many of the camps.
    Salmon- raw but explosive. Same thing they said about Jerel out of HS.
    Cooper- stud. Owned many of the top OL guys at camp.
    Jones- stud. Absolute beast at OLB. without questions going to be a starter on this D in a few years.
    Powell- stud. Playmaker. Most underrated guy in our class.
    Kilgore- good hands and frame. Could develop into the possession receiver this team needs.
    Chmura- don't know yet. Injured alot. But he has the potential.
    Hicks- stud. Plan A target from day 1.

    There are a few needs that we have to fill. But you can't tell me the guys we have in the fold are not good gets.

    Look at the 14 class- all our commits are top guys. You know Harris is just going to poop on whoever tries to cover him. Another Bullough another guy from Cass with a lot of speed.

    Your gloom and doom suggests that you haven't been following recruiting as closely as a tanfan should

    If all our guys are 'studs', then what does it say about the kids committed to the 30+ programs who are ranked ahead of us in the recruiting rankings?

    Employ some perspective. Our class is not nearly as exciting as your making it out to be.

    MarylandSpartan

  • 82msuspartan said...

    lWe really got the shaft on the scheduling end having to close out with Minny. Everyone else has rivalry game or high profile matchup for the last week. OSU-UM IU-Purdue Wisc-PSU Neb-Iowa Ill-NW.

    This is how it should have been laid out. Wisc-Minny Iowa-Neb Ill-NW IU-Purdue OSU-PSU MSU-UM.

    Read talk that after reallignment UM and OSU might end up in same division. Makes it sound like UM would go the leaders and they would become our protected rival.

    OSU, PSU, IU, Purdue, UM, Rutgers, Maryland

    Wisc, Neb, MSU, Iowa, Minny, Ill, NW.

    This would allign the league East/West and keep cometitive balance considering the PSU situation.

    um and OSU will NEVER be in the same division. It's ALL about sending one of those 2 teams to the NC game as far a Delaney is concerned. He wants the CCG to be um vs OSU every frickin' year, or he wants one of those 2 teams to be a 2nd place team in their division so they can jump the loser of the CCG and get the BCS bowl. That's god's plan.

    This post has been edited 2 times, most recently by spartan80 on 11/22/2012 at 4:57 PM

    spartan80

  • boozhoo said...

    i'm guessing MSU scores more than they have all year in conference and wins 31-17 and we all get even more pissed off at the thought of what could have been w/ 5 conference losses by a total of 13 points. it's insane how close we were all season to being a contender in conference. games ripped away from us week after week and stalling offense and untimely defensive collapses after playing lights out for 59 minutes. it's hard to fathom how much has gone wrong.

    But this saturday? A few things will finally go right and we'll go win a flea bag bowl - just enough to make everyone an apparently much needed dose of humility and hunger for 2013.

    Well, Minny is rolling with a true FR QB and their leading WR just quit the team. Defense hasn't been much of an issue this year, so if MSU can avoid TOs, they should be in great position to hold Minny to 17 or less.

    Now, whether MSU can score more than 17 . . . .

    Michigan State does not and will not run the 3-4 defense.

    SpartanRocky

  • Like someone said, it's amazing it has come down to this.

    Minnesota has beaten us a lot more than I would like to think about in my lifetime. On the road with our O (which can't score at home), I'm definitely worried, but I am giving this team my one last vote of confidence for the year. I say we likely win. Minny doesn't do anything too scary on offense right now and their D isn't that great. Plus I'm hoping MSU will play with some fire and have some pride. You might say this is more optimism than realism but I'm thinking we can get this done.

    Formerly Blade Runner.

    tManWithNoName

  • Seriously,

    I don't really care anymore.

    Thanks Roushar!

    Nίκη για MSU

    Bender

  • I would like to think MSU 24, Minny 14... but it depends on how deflated this team is (if so). Thanks to the lack of bowl eligible teams in the Big Ten, a win here means BWW bowl.

    RPGEnix0

  • no

    D will choke at the end like it always does.

    "Put your mother in a straight-jacket you punk ass white boy." ~ Mike Tyson

    tig ol bitties19581

  • spartan80 said...

    um and OSU will NEVER be in the same division. It's ALL about sending one of those 2 teams to the NC game as far a Delaney is concerned. He wants the CCG to be um vs OSU every frickin' year, or he wants one of those 2 teams to be a 2nd place team in their division so they can jump the loser of the CCG and get the BCS bowl. That's god's plan.

    Rexrode hinted at the UM/OSU thing in his weekly chat. The PSU scandal has the Big 10 rethinking the division allignment with the idea of maintaining competitive balance. PSU is really going to dive as a program soon as the sanctins and schollie limits take full effect. Not sure if the league wants back to back UM/OSU games which could happen the way the divisions are set now and those 2 playing final Sat. If they are going to be in opposite divisions then their rivalry game should be moved up in the season.

    82msuspartan

  • xYAxTRICKx said...

    If MSU gets a bowl invite at 5-7, they should turn it down. They don't deserve a bowl game.

    I agree. But I don't think 6-6 teams deserve a bowl bid either.

    Rodeo Burger

  • Bender said...

    Seriously,

    I don't really care anymore.

    Thanks Roushar!

    Sadly, I'm close to that.

    I do care, and I will always watch, but this team is the SOS. What sucks is they have the talent to be better, but aren't.

    With a soft schedule again the next 2 years (like we had last year), I expect a much better on paper performance. Depending on how it plays out, we might look OK in a bowl, as long as we underachieve in the regular season. If we overachieve, we'll get crushed in a good bowl.

    Rodeo Burger

  • MarylandSpartan said...

    If all our guys are 'studs', then what does it say about the kids committed to the 30+ programs who are ranked ahead of us in the recruiting rankings?

    Employ some perspective. Our class is not nearly as exciting as your making it out to be.

    I think his breakdown was a bit optimistic but you also need to enjoy a little perspective. Damion Terry will likely be a 4/5 star when the final rankings are announced. Cooper and Williams should be at least 4 stars. That would bump us into the top 25 when considering average star rating on rivals (which is the only ranking that counts). Can't really recruit 30 guys when you only have 14 scholarships. 2013 is a very good class I believe. 2014 needs to get moving and that's where my concern is.

    So far so good, both our ranked recruits have a good shot at being upgraded to 5 stars (Drake Harris and Deon Drake) and our unranked recruit is a Bullough, but as we know they tend to be pretty good. We just need more OL recruits.

    This post was edited by jimmywalker on 11/23/2012 at 2:12 AM

    jimmywalker

  • spartan80 said...

    um and OSU will NEVER be in the same division. It's ALL about sending one of those 2 teams to the NC game as far a Delaney is concerned. He wants the CCG to be um vs OSU every frickin' year, or he wants one of those 2 teams to be a 2nd place team in their division so they can jump the loser of the CCG and get the BCS bowl. That's god's plan.

    SCum and OSU will be in the same division with the next realignment. I can't see it being possible having them in opposite sides without making Nebraska go into an eastern division. OSU, UM, PSU, Rut, MD, IU, Pur, in the East. Neb, Wisc, MSU, Iowa, NW, Illinois, Minn in the West.

    jimmywalker

  • If scUM and OSU want their rivalry game to mean anything, they will get themselves into the same division. If they want it to keep becoming less relevant, they will stay in different divisions.

    Beardy

  • jimmywalker said...

    SCum and OSU will be in the same division with the next realignment. I can't see it being possible having them in opposite sides without making Nebraska go into an eastern division. OSU, UM, PSU, Rut, MD, IU, Pur, in the East. Neb, Wisc, MSU, Iowa, NW, Illinois, Minn in the West.

    Makes total sense and it seems like the obvious move. Then you can add UNC to the east and Kansas to the west when they come in. Delaney being a UNC alum and former Bball player could usher that move in as the ACC is going through massive change. Under that arrangement the B1G would become THE basketball conference that no one could match.

    FSU is looking to get out of the ACC and Clemson might be the other school the SEC may try to poach. The ACC will start to look like the old BE if they lost Maryland, Clemson, FSU and UNC.

    82msuspartan

  • We win in style. 63-2. Dark Mantonio takes over the offensive playcalling and unleashes hell, leaving us to wonder why it took 11 games of 110th ranked offense to do this.

    Oh and the 2 points is the safety that occurs when MD has to use the bathroom and lets Roushar do the playcalling. Next time hold it in, Coach!!

    tRCMB - "You'll leave feeling like you need to take a shower."

    AirItOutMaxwell

  • jimmywalker said...

    I think his breakdown was a bit optimistic but you also need to enjoy a little perspective. Damion Terry will likely be a 4/5 star when the final rankings are announced. Cooper and Williams should be at least 4 stars. That would bump us into the top 25 when considering average star rating on rivals (which is the only ranking that counts). Can't really recruit 30 guys when you only have 14 scholarships. 2013 is a very good class I believe. 2014 needs to get moving and that's where my concern is.

    So far so good, both our ranked recruits have a good shot at being upgraded to 5 stars (Drake Harris and Deon Drake) and our unranked recruit is a Bullough, but as we know they tend to be pretty good. We just need more OL recruits.

    2014 needs to get moving? Pretty sure it's our best start under dantonio so far. Relax dude

    signature image signature image signature image

    To die in ann arbor is redundant

    stoops21

  • Just to make people feel even more depressed: We beat Georgia in our bowl game. Georgia is currently ranked 3rd and has a chance at a national title. We are 5-6 and have a 3 page thread asking "Will we beat Minnesota?"

    Sigh.

    Formerly Blade Runner.

    tManWithNoName

  • tManWithNoName said...

    Just to make people feel even more depressed: We beat Georgia in our bowl game. Georgia is currently ranked 3rd and has a chance at a national title. We are 5-6 and have a 3 page thread asking "Will we beat Minnesota?"

    Sigh.

    All you can do is sigh and then laugh.

    tRCMB - "You'll leave feeling like you need to take a shower."

    AirItOutMaxwell

  • tManWithNoName said...

    Just to make people feel even more depressed: We beat Georgia in our bowl game. Georgia is currently ranked 3rd and has a chance at a national title. We are 5-6 and have a 3 page thread asking "Will we beat Minnesota?"

    Sigh.

    Well, UGA recruits circles around us. Its about the Jimmy and Joes not the X's and O's.

    SpartanHoops

  • I think/hope this team comes out fired up. I'm sure they don't want to be the ones who break the bowl streak.

    21 - 17, MSU.

    TX Sparty

  • We will win 7-3

    SD Spartan

  • I think for once we put it all together and get out of Minny with a resounding...10 point victory. We'll be up 16-13 and score a TD with 2 minutes left. Maxwell to Burbridge.

    "RCMB: You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villainry." - some dude from MgoBlog

    JEK

  • 82msuspartan said...

    Makes total sense and it seems like the obvious move. Then you can add UNC to the east and Kansas to the west when they come in. Delaney being a UNC alum and former Bball player could usher that move in as the ACC is going through massive change. Under that arrangement the B1G would become THE basketball conference that no one could match.

    FSU is looking to get out of the ACC and Clemson might be the other school the SEC may try to poach. The ACC will start to look like the old BE if they lost Maryland, Clemson, FSU and UNC.

    I think UNC is the next add and ND gets one last offer before Kansas gets an offer. There still needs to be an East Coast league I'm just not sure how the ACC survives.

    jimmywalker