Online Now 1590

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

On this Board 894
Record: 12118 (3/18/2012)

Online now 1452
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

tOfficial Case Closed on Paterno's Legacy

  • Sparts said...

    Then how do you explain this?

    "The e-mails also would suggest Paterno knew more than he said: On Feb. 26, 2001, CNN reported, Schultz suggests contacting authorities, but the next night, Curley writes to Spanier that after talking with Paterno, he would like to "work with" Sandusky instead."

    Like I said, it doesn't look good at all, but no one knows what Paterno said in that meeting. More facts are needed.

    PRStoetzer

  • rookmsu said...

    Why would anyone believe anything he says?

    Hey, no one believes Casey Anthony but people would tune in if she gave a network interview. People love to listen to the crazies.

    I personally think he'll kill himself or a prison inmate will beat him to it. I'd be surprised if he makes it a year.

    signature image

    RCMB Join Date: September 2001

    Pinky Tuscadero

  • PRStoetzer said...

    Like I said, it doesn't look good at all, but no one knows what Paterno said in that meeting. More facts are needed.

    If this were a criminal trial we might need a bit more, but in the world of tRCMB he is guilty. What more do you need, a picture of him with a smoking gun?

    http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2012/06/david_jones_joe_paterno_fans_m.html

    signature image signature image signature image

    Sparts

  • Did anyone ever ask Paterno or McQueary directly why they did not contact the police over child rape and/or never follow up? That still baffles me.

    Rilian

  • JoePa is the scapegoat, can't you see they are throwing him under the bus because he's dead and can't defend himself..

    Jahlil Suggs

  • Jahlil Suggs said...

    JoePa is the scapegoat, can't you see they are throwing him under the bus because he's dead and can't defend himself..

    Dude, take the halo off the man. For anyone to still believe JoPa knew nothing and was a saint of a man, they're either really stupid, blindly ignorant or have been in a coma for a few years.

    signature image

    RCMB Join Date: September 2001

    Pinky Tuscadero

  • Jahlil Suggs said...

    JoePa is the scapegoat, can't you see they are throwing him under the bus because he's dead and can't defend himself..

    I hope you are bring sarcastic........

    mopete95

  • Sparts said...

    If this were a criminal trial we might need a bit more, but in the world of tRCMB he is guilty. What more do you need, a picture of him with a smoking gun?

    http://www.pennlive.com/midstate/index.ssf/2012/06/david_jones_joe_paterno_fans_m.html

    Wow.

    Posting member of tRCMB since 1997. It is ALWAYS a great day to be a Spartan!!!!

    Raytooth Morgan

  • Pinky Tuscadero said...

    Dude, take the halo off the man. For anyone to still believe JoPa knew nothing and was a saint of a man, they're either really stupid, blindly ignorant or have been in a coma for a few years.

    Consider the poster and remember that sarcasm exists in this world. You just got played.

    Posting member of tRCMB since 1997. It is ALWAYS a great day to be a Spartan!!!!

    Raytooth Morgan

  • I used to think that JoePa was a pretty normal guy, much like my pop. Similar age, similar look and demeanor. But my pop would have beat the living fuck out of sandusky, and what was left of him he would have bagged and dropped off at the police station with a note explaining the situation.

    Im very disappointed in what I have heard from top to bottom at Penn State. Paternos football coaching ability remains highly regarded. But as a man, his legacy went down the terlit. Screw Penn State. I hope the football program rots in hell with its coaches.

    If you laugh, you think, and you cry, that's a full day. That's a heck of a day. Jimmy Valvano

    GatorBill

  • Jahlil Suggs said...

    JoePa is the scapegoat, can't you see they are throwing him under the bus because he's dead and can't defend himself..

    Nucky said the same thing...word for word.

    Oh wait...you are Nucky.

    tVargMan Prime

  • PRStoetzer said...

    Like I said, it doesn't look good at all, but no one knows what Paterno said in that meeting. More facts are needed.

    I'm all for waiting for things to play out a lot of times but we know that PSU officials had pretty much catered to Joe Pa's wishes for a very long time, and whatever he said to Curley made Curley change his mind. This is a personal e-mail so it's doubtful he is lying about it. We don't truly need facts to form our own opinions on a message board, we aren't a jury. But I think that right there is a pretty good indicator something was up. Chances are as far a this particular story goes we aren't going to ever truly know what Joe Pa knew because he is no longer with us, but I know that at first I didn't want to believe Joe Pa was complicit in all of this, but almost everything I have come across since have lead me to change my mind. I certainly wasn't quick to condemn him but there's just too much that doesn't add up to ignore.

    Formerly Blade Runner.

    tManWithNoName

  • It was and still is my opinion that Joe Paterno did not die of Lung Cancer, he died of a guilty conscience. He knew the writing was on the wall and to think he had the audacity to try to finish out the year.

    This post was edited by SPARKYRULES on 7/2/2012 at 5:50 PM

    SPARKYRULES

  • PRStoetzer said...

    I think people are reading too much into those emails. They don't look good for Joe, that's for sure, but they are too vague to really say for certain what Joe knew and what he did.

    That's what JoePa's family says.

    Although perhaps they themselves hold the smoking gun, and are hiding it:

    Paterno's appointment book could serve as a confirmation that he met with Curley on or around the date Curley says they met, Feb. 27, 2001. Or it could exonerate him, showing Paterno was off on vacation or unavailable for even a phone conversation. While it often lacked great detail, for a Penn State community desperate for any facts or explanations, the appointment book could offer a morsel of truth.

    Unfortunately it doesn't; at least not yet.

    The library's collection of Paterno appointment books run from 1985 to 2000, the last entry being Dec. 30, 2000. There is nothing from 2001 until Paterno's firing in November 2011.

    Seven weeks after the last item in the appointment book, Curley's email stated that he and the iconic coach talked about how to handle Sandusky. There is no publicly available documentation that the meeting did or didn't occur, let alone the subjects discussed.

    The paperwork of Paterno's whereabouts ending so close to these critical days appears to be coincidental.

    There was an initial donation by the Paternos to the library in 2001, according to school officials. That explains the cutoff in 2000, as the 2001 book would still have been in use. The family did not donate additional documents that included appointment books or schedule confirmations, regrets or cancellations.

    "The Paterno papers inventory represent the Paterno materials currently housed by the Library," Jackie R. Esposito, university archivist and head of the school's Records Management Programs. "The family has not donated any subsequent personal papers."

    It's possible the Paterno family has that information. The anticipated Freeh Commission report on the Sandusky case may provide additional context or information into Paterno's role.

    State College, PA - Paterno Family Wants Freeh, Attorney General's Office to Release All Emails and Records

    Three days after emails were leaked to CNN indicating former Penn State football coach Joe Paterno was allegedly involved in the cover-up of Jerry Sandusky's child sexual abuse, the Paterno family fired back for the second time since Saturday.

    www.statecollege.com

    Joe Paterno's appointment books shed no light on whether Tim Curley is telling the truth - Yahoo! Sports

    From Yahoo! Sports: Appointment books open to the public extend through 2000, and the key meeting supposedly occurred in February 2001.

    sports.yahoo.com

    SpartanInNH

  • rookmsu said...

    Why would anyone believe anything he says?

    Speaking in super broad generalities; pedophiles aren't known to lie. They don't view what they're doing as wrong, so they have no real incentive to lie.

    signature image

    RBW Spartan

  • RBW Spartan said...

    Speaking in super broad generalities; pedophiles aren't known to lie. They don't view what they're doing as wrong, so they have no real incentive to lie.

    That is a broad generality, but acknowledging it as such, I agree with your statements. Pedophiles generally see what they are doing as teaching love in a loving fashion, and feel that if people just "understood" what they were doing, people would see their actions for what they "are" -- "loving."

    SpartanInNH

  • john winger said...

    i will say my peace again in this thread. IMHO, PSU needs to take a self-imposed 2 year ban and not play football until 2015. its becoming apparent that many folks at PSU, high up in the football program and university, brushed this aside for YEARS for the sake of keeping PSU in the football limelight, thus keeping money coming into the school and program. if it was about money then, it should be about money now and PSU should suffer mightily from a cash flow perspective and receive none for the next 2 years.

    i would also hope that the NCAA would let all the kids transfer, without penalty, and get to play somewhere else immediately. no need to punish the current roster of kids.

    I agree completely. Let the kids go anywhere, and for people that are saying they are punishing the current students, they are free to transfer as well, and there is more to PSU then Football, it is a very good academic institute. Hell they can watch Cael and the wrestling team win National Titles.

    signature image signature image

    DMBSparty

  • Joe Pa didn't rape little boys. Case closed.

    The media is corrupt. When will you guys realize the truth will never get out? They base all of this on emails and log books. You think (88 year old) Joe Pa would ever use email?

    This post has been edited 3 times, most recently by Spartan8Ball on 7/2/2012 at 7:01 PM

    signature image

    Spartan8Ball

  • SpartanInNH said...

    That's what JoePa's family says.

    Although perhaps they themselves hold the smoking gun, and are hiding it:

    Paterno's appointment book could serve as a confirmation that he met with Curley on or around the date Curley says they met, Feb. 27, 2001. Or it could exonerate him, showing Paterno was off on vacation or unavailable for even a phone conversation. While it often lacked great detail, for a Penn State community desperate for any facts or explanations, the appointment book could offer a morsel of truth.

    Unfortunately it doesn't; at least not yet.

    The library's collection of Paterno appointment books run from 1985 to 2000, the last entry being Dec. 30, 2000. There is nothing from 2001 until Paterno's firing in November 2011.

    Seven weeks after the last item in the appointment book, Curley's email stated that he and the iconic coach talked about how to handle Sandusky. There is no publicly available documentation that the meeting did or didn't occur, let alone the subjects discussed.

    The paperwork of Paterno's whereabouts ending so close to these critical days appears to be coincidental.

    There was an initial donation by the Paternos to the library in 2001, according to school officials. That explains the cutoff in 2000, as the 2001 book would still have been in use. The family did not donate additional documents that included appointment books or schedule confirmations, regrets or cancellations.

    "The Paterno papers inventory represent the Paterno materials currently housed by the Library," Jackie R. Esposito, university archivist and head of the school's Records Management Programs. "The family has not donated any subsequent personal papers."

    It's possible the Paterno family has that information. The anticipated Freeh Commission report on the Sandusky case may provide additional context or information into Paterno's role.

    Paterno stopped doing the appointment books because he knew they would be incriminating to Sandusky and to all of his cover up efforts.

    tVargMan Prime

  • Rilian said...

    Did anyone ever ask Paterno or McQueary directly why they did not contact the police over child rape and/or never follow up? That still baffles me.

    McQuery was asked. He said he went to VP Gary Schultz who was the head of Campus Police who has jurisdiction over the place he saw the crime. McQuery regretted the decision, but at the time he thought by going to him he was going to the Police.

    signature image

    RPMadMSU

  • Fuck it. Joe knew this would be a mess and wanted it handled in a way that would benefit PSU not the kids. I'm convinced of that now and he can kiss my ass. I'm pissed that a great human being like Kirk Cousins was gracious enough to insert patterno in his speech last year and think PSU owes him a public apology now.

    My dad always told me, you can build a thousand bridges, but if you suck one cock you'll always be known as a cock sucker. Joe, you sucked a cock.

    signature image signature image signature image

    DWags

  • Spartan8Ball said...

    Joe Pa didn't rape little boys. Case closed.

    The media is corrupt. When will you guys realize the truth will never get out? They base all of this on emails and log books. You think (88 year old) Joe Pa would ever use email?

    Just because the family says he didn't use email, doesn't mean he didn't, and if he did, there WILL be evidence of it.

    Consider also: if the others knew JoePa didn't communicate by email, all of their contact with him would have been over the phone. They still could have emailed each other (which is apparent) and JoePa could have been solidly in the mix anyway.

    (And those opening statements by you prove you are an idiot).

    Vegas Vic

  • Make them wear a red P on their jerseys for 7 years.

    hoke- to alter or manipulate so as to give a deceptively or superficially improved quality or value.

    The Doctor

  • I think the Paterno discussion is obscuring / side-tracking people at this point.

    Whether Paterno was involved or not, it's certain there was a cover up. It's equally certain that high-ranking university and athletic department officials were involved in the cover up. The primary motive is to protect the university image, and a benefit of that is also protecting a revenue stream, and a factor that attracts students etc. This absolutely should fall under NCAA jurisdiction or DoE jurisdiction as people have suggested. And there has to be a punishment to correct the ill-gotten gain. That punishment should be the harshest ever handed down by the NCAA or DoE or whoever it ends up being. 2 years of no football seems like a minimum.

    In terms of the fans and current students suffering -- too bad. We as sports fans are quick to bask in the glory of present and past championships -- but we had no hand in achieving them. It should be understood that future ignominy is shared as well. That's the cost that gets paid for putting a program or university image on a pedestal so high that you protect a pedophile.

    Think about it this way -- movies about the Holocaust get made at regular intervals for the last 60+ years. Germans today didn't have a hand in that holocaust, but they still pay some sort of price in terms of having to relive their country's actions again and again. Of course, there's no way you can compare the holocaust to what happened at Penn State, but that's why there won't be moves made every year for the next century, and war-crimes trials etc. over Sandusky's actions. A 2-year football ban is a proportional response, IMO.

    TheAxMan

  • D.Wags said...

    You can build a thousand bridges, but if you suck one cock you'll always be known as a cock sucker.

    This could be the message on one of those inspirational, Franklin Covey-esque posters.

    I'm picturing a man standing on the Golden Gate bridge. But I'm not sure what else should be on the poster.

    msu98