Online Now 2336

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

On this Board 129
Record: 3425 (1/27/2013)

Online now 2463
Record: 10351 (3/11/2012)

Boards ▾

MSU Red Cedar Message Board

The largest and most active MSU Spartans board on the web

The Press Box

The place to ask questions to SpartanTailgate's recruiting experts

Duffy Daugherty Forum

"The Duff" is dedicated to Michigan State football recruiting discussion

Jack Breslin Forum

"The Bres" is dedicated to Michigan State basketball recruiting discussion

Wells Hall Off Topic Board

This is your pulpit to preach to the masses about everything from politics to religion

Marketplace & Ticket Exchange

The place to buy, trade or sell Michigan State tickets

Fantasy Sports Forum

For fantasy football and other fantasy sports discussion

Test/Feedback Forum

Reply

This is exactly how to solve black/white racism......

  • Beastial said...

    Please don't get me started on the Jews and their insistence we don't forget about The (so called) Holocaust and all the museums that memorialize it - even preserving "death" camps in Europe. Just get over it!

    We have a Jew hater. (so called) manifested your bigotry. I bet you have lots of friends.

    Keeping the sunshiners in check since 2000.

    Tanfan

  • Why are some of you suggesting that only white people are racist?

    Ogie Ogilthorpe

  • MindlessChaos said...

    Not.. no As long as you keep looking in the past at these things, the longer it will be before "racism" is a thing of the past. ( though obviously never completely eliminated) WHY would you collect this stuff? (Especially if you are black?) Only thing someone should do with the "memorabilia" is burn it.

    It is important to remember these things because as the old saying goes " Those who fail to remember the mistakes of the past are doomed to repeat them."

    Madhatter536

  • Ogie Ogilthorpe said...

    Why are some of you suggesting that only white people are racist?

    No one is suggesting that only white people are racist. What I'm saying is that white people are far more likely to ignore the pervasive racism in America and claim that they are living in a "post-racial" society. You will meet very few black people who agree with that claim, and it's not because they're "feeling sorry for themselves." It's because they have to deal with the realities of both structural and individual racism every day.

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • I'm only racist against tan lawyers, and the dutch.

    This post was edited by Motown Spartan on 4/22/2012 at 8:55 AM

    Motown Spartan

  • Nothing like a bunch of white people telling blacks how to solve racism.

    Don't think -- it can only hurt the ballclub

    LA_Spartan

  • Nitro Biscuits said...

    I'm curious where you see that. It's possible I'm missing something that you are not.

    I'm on my iPhone, but here are two excerpts from two separate posters:

    "crushing sense of worthlessness on the white working class that forces them to take refuge in any sense of superiority available to them.

    Statements like this are evidence that we are nowhere near the "post-racial" society in which so many white Americans claim to live."

    And the post directly above mine works too.

    This post was edited by Ogie Ogilthorpe on 4/22/2012 at 9:09 AM

    Ogie Ogilthorpe

  • fishrose said...

    No one is arguing that American racism and the holocaust were of equal severity in terms of loss of life. However, they were both morally reprehensible acts in which a massive group of human beings was treated as sub-human simply because they were different. While the events themselves are too different for a direct comparison, the lasting effects of those events and the reactions to them are too similar to avoid a direct comparison.

    Saying "well, slavery and Jim Crow racism was better than the holocaust" is like saying "well, at least the Oklahoma City bombing was better than 9/11."

    I agree for the most part. On the part of genocide, I do believe that goes beyond the stage of "sub-human" however. That is the reason I did not feel it was an accurate comparison. My main reason against this "Collection" is that any real " racist Memorabilia" is not worthy of being kept. Some of what they showed was not to the extent that I feel it could not have some redeeming value by showing it, but some items such as KKK's propaganda represent such extreme cases that I feel it should be destroyed. This was a private collection I believe before it was made a museum piece which is why I questioned why someone of African descent would put together such a collection as a hobby. I don't see Jews collections Swastikas and I don't expect to find one. ( though obviously there could easily be several) Maybe I take this to more of the extreme then others do. I am part German and I have all but renounced that because the horrors of the holocaust sicken me to that extent. I despise inequality and injustice and I just feel the more past racism get's brought up, ( specifically white racism) the more our progress will regress and we will breed more racism. Now not only do we have to deal with racism ( or perceived racism) , but class warfare is also becoming more widespread. I am no where near the 1% but discriminating against them because of their wealth is very similar to discriminating against someone due to the color of their skin.

    MindlessChaos

  • fishrose said...

    No one is suggesting that only white people are racist. What I'm saying is that white people are far more likely to ignore the pervasive racism in America and claim that they are living in a "post-racial" society. You will meet very few black people who agree with that claim, and it's not because they're "feeling sorry for themselves." It's because they have to deal with the realities of both structural and individual racism every day.

    I am more likely to ignore the reverse discrimination, but it gets harder every day that I have to hear we are not doing enough while in my personal experience some stereotypes have unfortunately been accurate more often than should be expected. I was not alive to reap the benefits of being Caucasian, so why should I be penalized for being Caucasian now? I would honestly say that there are a lot of issues which could result in a new wave in racism primarily being linked to the "ghetto" mentality in general. ( A mentality linked to "African"- Americans a large majority of the time) The glorification of that lifestyle in black media and actual life circumstances has a severe negative impact in that regard. The only people I know who has a strong racial preference are those who has been strongly turned off by that mentality and "African" Americans in general as a result. (I would not say to the extent of actual racism but enough to discourage them.)

    MindlessChaos

  • MindlessChaos said...

    I am more likely to ignore the reverse discrimination, but it gets harder every day that I have to hear we are not doing enough while in my personal experience some stereotypes have unfortunately been accurate more often than should be expected. I was not alive to reap the benefits of being Caucasian, so why should I be penalized for being Caucasian now? I would honestly say that there are a lot of issues which could result in a new wave in racism primarily being linked to the "ghetto" mentality in general. ( A mentality linked to "African"- Americans a large majority of the time) The glorification of that lifestyle in black media and actual life circumstances has a severe negative impact in that regard. The only people I know who has a strong racial preference are those who has been strongly turned off by that mentality and "African" Americans in general as a result. (I would not say to the extent of actual racism but enough to discourage them.)

    Name one instance in your life where you were meaningfully disadvantaged due to being "Caucasian." I won't hold my breath...

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • Nitro Biscuits said...

    Actually America has loved the "outlaw" since it's inception. Gansta's mentality today is actually just a ripoff of previous myths of outlaws and gangsters of yesterday.

    You are crossing your wires as far as what you see as a result of race and what is a result of economic status. Black people have a much higher percentage people below the poverty line. The average black kid has a far less likely chance of having had any one in the family go to college before them. The average black kid is far more likely to be raised below the poverty line in less than ideal education conditions.

    Is it their fault that they came from a slave background as a group? That this inherent disadvantage, combined with previous racism, made it very difficult for a black person attain an education and succeed at a level that a typical white person, at the time, would consider success?

    Now realize that jim crow laws were still around within many peoples life times. Just because we have made massive strides in the last century don't believe for a second that it's a perfectly level playing field. You said so yourself. You see first hand the stereotypes being true. A black person has to overcome your bias from that observation. Not his/her fault.

    They came from a slave background? FYI slavery was outlawed in the U.S. in 1865. Are they 147 years old?

    Συν ται η επι ται! Syn tai e epi tai! Ή ταν ή επί τας! E tan i epi tas!

    CVSpartan

  • Beastial said...

    Please don't get me started on the Jews and their insistence we don't forget about The (so called) Holocaust and all the museums that memorialize it - even preserving "death" camps in Europe. Just get over it!

    Vehemently disagree.

    The saying is "those who forget history are doomed to repeat it"

    This is clear today. For example, many people are ignorant of the European economies or what is happening in countries like Argentina now and Venezuela, yet US is moving in same direction, making same mistakes.

    It is very dangerous to forget the past as they surely will become the future.

    Green Note

  • MindlessChaos said...

    I agree for the most part. On the part of genocide, I do believe that goes beyond the stage of "sub-human" however. That is the reason I did not feel it was an accurate comparison. My main reason against this "Collection" is that any real " racist Memorabilia" is not worthy of being kept. Some of what they showed was not to the extent that I feel it could not have some redeeming value by showing it, but some items such as KKK's propaganda represent such extreme cases that I feel it should be destroyed. This was a private collection I believe before it was made a museum piece which is why I questioned why someone of African descent would put together such a collection as a hobby. I don't see Jews collections Swastikas and I don't expect to find one. ( though obviously there could easily be several) Maybe I take this to more of the extreme then others do. I am part German and I have all but renounced that because the horrors of the holocaust sicken me to that extent. I despise inequality and injustice and I just feel the more past racism get's brought up, ( specifically white racism) the more our progress will regress and we will breed more racism. Now not only do we have to deal with racism ( or perceived racism) , but class warfare is also becoming more widespread. I am no where near the 1% but discriminating against them because of their wealth is very similar to discriminating against someone due to the color of their skin.

    This is not equivalent to a Jew collecting swastikas. If you want to make that comparison, this is more similar to a holocaust museum collecting Anti-Jew propaganda posters, and most of them do. If you are being genuine about your aversion to inequality and injustice, I have to assume that you haven't seen the ways in which racial discrimination has destroyed the ability of millions of black Americans to participate in mainstream society. There's a reason that poverty and crime disproportionately affect blacks, and it certainly isn't because blacks are somehow inherently lazy or violent.

    Even overlooking the very significant issues of past discrimination and generational poverty, blacks are significantly disadvantaged in most urban areas today. This is largely due to the extreme commercial disinvestment in black neighborhoods. With very few options for low-skill employment (important for both young people and under-educated adults) within a reasonable distance, many black men and women turn to alternative economies (including illegal trades) to provide for their families. Those participating in legal alternative economies like in-kind exchange of services are essentially locked into poverty because the majority of resources they gain through their labor cannot be invested or saved in a bank. Those participating in illegal alternative economies are disproportionately arrested and incarcerated because catching drug dealers and prostitutes concentrated in ghettos is like shooting fish in a barrel whereas it requires much more time and effort to track down and prosecute the same type of criminals in more private, suburban areas. Although some blacks have been able to break out of this cycle, the fact of the matter is that there are many, many more black workers than there are accessible jobs for them in the mainstream economy. They are the lucky few, an exception, not the rule.

    The root cause of these (and other) problems that disproportionately affect blacks is the overt racism of the pre-civil rights era. The problems are perpetuated by modern "politically corrected" racism, as well as the false notion that society is equal and these inequalities are the result of free market forces. Because both the cause and effects of these problems are racial in nature, many solutions to them are racial in nature as well. This is not, however, "reverse discrimination" as many would have you believe. No one is talking about denying whites home loans or arbitrarily increasing their insurance rates. Most affirmative action policies are intended to simply level the playing field on a statistical, if not individual, level. Simply put, the goal of affirmative action is to increase the degree to which minority representation in education, business, and government reflects the proportions of the population at large.

    I would argue that these types of policies are only necessary within the context of the currently subsidized economic investment and residential development patterns in America. A more efficient and effective solution would be a comprehensive federal policy for eliminating urban poverty and improving the quality of life in American inner cities. Unfortunately, the means to reach such an end involve stepping on a lot of toes in special interest groups. Oil and automotive interests lobby against improving mass transit. Construction and real estate interests lobby against any reduction in the subsidy of suburban sprawl. For-profit education companies and the privatized prison complex lobby against investment in inner-city public schools. For these reasons, any realistic attempt at moving toward equality must use race as a major criteria.

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • This museum should not be in MI. Museums should represent the history of their area. It would be far more appropriate to be in Selma, AL.

    Συν ται η επι ται! Syn tai e epi tai! Ή ταν ή επί τας! E tan i epi tas!

    CVSpartan

  • Let me add the following:

    1. Slavery was never legal in MI. It was specifically outlawed in the Nortwest Ordinance for all the terrority now known as the Midwest.

    2. Jim Crow was never a fact of life in MI in that it was never incorporated into the state and local laws as it was in deep south.

    Συν ται η επι ται! Syn tai e epi tai! Ή ταν ή επί τας! E tan i epi tas!

    CVSpartan

  • CVSpartan said...

    They came from a slave background? FYI slavery was outlawed in the U.S. in 1865. Are they 147 years old?

    Blantant and overt racial discrimination in most industries was not outlawed until 1968. Are all black people under the age of 44? Can the negative consequences of discrimination be entirely erased in just 44 years?

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • There will always be racism as long as there is an emphasis on race and power associated with it.

    Would Obama have been elected tot he Presidency is he were not black? Recall that he was the one who introduced race into the campaign. If there were no political advantage what would be the point of doing it?

    There is a race industry. These people need to perpetuate "racism" to make a buck.

    Green Note

  • CVSpartan said...

    2. Jim Crow was never a fact of life in MI in that it was never incorporated into the state and local laws as it was in deep south.

    Jim Crow was always a fact of life in Michigan. It was simply never put into law. In fact, the negative effects of Jim Crow are more damaging and lasting in northern cities because no legal action could be taken to reverse the effects of discrimination during the civil rights era. In the south, court-ordered busing, lending quotas, and hiring requirements did a lot to undo the damage caused by segregation. That's why cities like Atlanta and Birmingham are less segregated and more racially progressive in the modern day than cities like Detroit, Cleveland, and Chicago.

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • I don't deny there was as and still is discrimination. It is as stretch to keep talking about slavery though.

    I have no doubt that absolutely everyone on the planet is descended from slaves since it was a vile and widely practiced institution. Certainly pervasive in the Roman, Greek and Ottoman empires among all races.

    Συν ται η επι ται! Syn tai e epi tai! Ή ταν ή επί τας! E tan i epi tas!

    CVSpartan

  • Nope. Jim Crow was incorporated in the laws in the deep south. That is what it means. Discrimination is another matter.

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Crow_laws

    This post was edited by CVSpartan on 4/22/2012 at 11:05 AM

    Συν ται η επι ται! Syn tai e epi tai! Ή ταν ή επί τας! E tan i epi tas!

    CVSpartan

  • CVSpartan said...

    I don't deny there was as and still is discrimination. It is as stretch to keep talking about slavery though.

    I have no doubt that absolutely everyone on the planet is descended from slaves since it was a vile and widely practiced institution. Certainly pervasive in the Roman, Greek and Ottoman empires among all races.

    You are the only one who is still talking about slavery. Nitro Biscuits mentioned it as a factor in the origin of modern black poverty, but he also mentioned the discrimination since that time as a more important issue. Slaves could not own property, and the laws and private-sector policies of the following years were specifically tailored to prevent blacks from owning property and accumulating wealth.

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • Nitro Biscuits said...

    You grossly underestimate the effect of one generation on the next.

    The upward mobility from one generation to the next isn't that great already and that's without a century of institutionalized racist policy.

    What was the chance of the first gen of free born black americans of going to college? 0? 2nd generation? 0? 3rd?

    What was the chance of a first gen of free born black american of being able to obtain the financial success of the average white american at that time? In all the generations since has that caught up?

    If you are a black kid today, are you less likely to have family money waiting to pay for your education? Are you more likely to live in an area with a substandard school?

    Uh there were colleges established for blacks in the south. Ever hear of Howard University? The one started by the former union general O. O. Howard?

    Συν ται η επι ται! Syn tai e epi tai! Ή ταν ή επί τας! E tan i epi tas!

    CVSpartan

  • CVSpartan said...

    Nope. Jim Crow was incorporated in the laws in the deep south. That is what it means. Discrimination is another matter.

    You're arguing semantics. Segregation and discrimination were very real in Michigan well into the post-Civil Rights era. This de facto segregation was harder to eliminate than the de jure segregation in the deep south, and it was equally damaging from a social and economic standpoint.

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose

  • Let's see the current President is black as is the Attorney General and 2 of the last 3 Secretaries of State. Living in the past much?

    Studies like that hurt the cause of minorities cause it makes them think they are hated and they have no chance in life.

    As we all know life can be very hard for all. Sometimes it REALLY REALLY sucks.

    The key is not giving up.

    Συν ται η επι ται! Syn tai e epi tai! Ή ταν ή επί τας! E tan i epi tas!

    CVSpartan

  • CVSpartan said...

    Let's see the current President is black as is the Attorney General and 2 of the last 3 Secretaries of State. Living in the past much?

    Studies like that hurt the cause of minorities cause it makes them think they are hated and they have no chance in life.

    As we all know life can be very hard for all. Sometimes it REALLY REALLY sucks.

    The key is not giving up.

    Why don't you go to Dexter and Collingwood in Detroit and tell me if your life has ever been that hard?

    signature image

    tRCMB's resident Wayne State Warrior and Sam's Club Spartan fan.

    fishrose